Vnutrennyaya_politika_Turtsii_2002-2018

6paTheB-MYCYJibMaH IOcy<Pa aJib-Kap,n;ami, 3p,n;oraH H BOBCe MO)KeT CTaTb xaJIH<!>OM BHOBh o6pa30BaHHOrO HCJiaMCKoro rocy,n;apCTBa co CTOJimi;e:H B CTaM6yJie. Tio MHeHHIO 6oroCJioBa, OH BepeH Kopatty, map11ary H cyttHe, a Bee rypeu;KHe MycyJihMaHe ,n;OJI)l{HhI «npHCRTHYTh eMy Ha BepHOCTh» H «BCTaTb Ha era CTOpOtty»l.

3p,n;oraH )Ke B OTBeT Ha 3TO npe,n;oCTaBHJI y6e)KHIIJ;e JIH,n;epaM ,ll;BH)KeHlliI IlOCJie BOeHHOro nepeBopoTa B ErHnTe, BCJie,ll;CTBHe qero B Typu;HH 6hIJI OTKpbIT o<Pttc 3TOH opraHH3aIJ;MH. Ba)KHO, 'ITOM BO BpeM51 caMoro nepeBOpoTa Typu;llil COBMeCTHO c KarnpoM OKa3bIBaJia 3Ha'IMTeJihHYIOno,n;,n;ep)l{Ky CBeprHYTOMY Il03)Ke M. MypcH, KOTOpbIH TaK)Ke HMeJI TeCHbie CB513H c rpynIlMpOBKOH «EpaTh51-MYCYJibMaHe», H CTaJia O,ll;HOH 113 HeMHOrHx CTpaH, ocy- ,ll;MBllIMX nepeBopoT 2013 r. 2 Bee 3TH ,n;e:HcTBlliI HarJI51,ll;HO ,n;eMOHCTpHpyioT, HaCKOJibKO TeCHhl B3aHMOOTHOllieHH51 Me)K,ll;y TypeIJ;KHM JIH,n;epoM H O,ll;HOH H3 HaH60Jiee aBTOpMTeTHhIX MCJiaMCKHX accou;11au;11:H.

TaKHM o6pa3oM, Ha npoTJI)KeHHM 2000-x rr. Typu;HJI cyMeJia npH,n;aTh IlOJIQ)KHTeJihHYIO ,ll;MHaMHKy OTHOllieHlliIM co BCeMH KJIIO'leBhIMMHrpoKaMM EJIM)l{Hero BocToKa, OCHOBOH ,ll;Jl5I KOTOphIX CTaJIO o6IIJ;ee ttCJiaMcKoe Ha'laJIO. I1MeHHO 3TOT nptt3HaK CTaJI KJIIO'leBhIM,ll;Jl5I onpe,n;eJieHM51 BHellIHeilOJIMTMqecKOH aKTMEHOCTM Typu;tttt. Tio,n;TBep)K,ll;aeT 3TO M OTHOllieHMe 3p,n;oraHa K «EpaTh51M-MYCYJibMaHaM». TipttMe'laTeJihHO,'ITOBee 3TM marM npoxo,n;HJIM Ha <l>oHe HeCTa6HJihHhIX OTHOllieHMH c EBpono:H.

l13 Ha3BaHHhIX <l>aKTOpOB CJie,n;yeT, 'ITOnpM BM,ll;MMOH BeCTepHM3aIJ;MM o6IIJ;eCTBa Typu;tt51 rrpo,n;OJI)KaJia OCTaBaTbC51 rny6oKO MCJiaMM3MpOBaHHOH CTpaHo:H. EJitt30CTh peJittrtto3HhIX ,ll;)KaMaaToB K BJiaCTHhIM cTpyKTypaM no-npe)l{HeMy ocTanaJiach; 3Ha'lttTeJihHOpacmttpttJiacb c<Pepa BJIM51HM51 YrrpaBJieHM51 no ,n;eJiaM peJIMrMM, KOTopoe OTKphIBaJIO HOBhie peJIMrH03Hhie llIKOJlhl M YHMBepcttTeThl 110 BCeH CTpaHe, a TaK)Ke Harrp51MYIO BMellIMBaJIOCh B IlOBCe,n;HeBHYIO )Klf3Hh rpa)K,n;aH MCJiaMCKMMM HOBOBBe,n;eHM51MM.

HaKoHeu;, cepbe3Hoe yrJiy6JieHtte coTpy,n;Htt'lecTBaco BCeMM 6Jitt)l(HeBocTo'IHhIMMCTpaHaMM rroKa3aJIO, 'ITOTypu;ttJI ,ll;YMaJia He TOJihKO o rrp03arra,n;- HOM ITYTM pa3BMTM51. K TOMY )Ke TaKoro po,n;a HarrpaBJieHHOCTh rroJIMTMKM MO)KHO 6bIJIO O)KH,n;aTh OT rrpaBJIIIJ;e:H TICP M B oco6eHHOCTM OT P. T. 3p,n;o- raHa, KOTOpbIH He TOJlhKO Ha'IMHaJIIlOJIMTM'leCKMHITYTh B COCTaBe MCJiaMMCTCKMX rrapTMH, HO M rrorra,n;aJI 110,ll; CTpa)Ky 3a ,n;eKJiapttpOBaHMe CTMXOB MCJiaMMCTCKoro co,n;ep)KaHlliI M rrporraraH,n;y MCJiaMM3Ma. I1 KaK 6br HM CTapaJIMCh JIH,n;ephr TICP 3aByaJittpoBaTh H,n;ett o pacrrpocTpaHeHMM MCJiaMa rro,n; rpOMKMMM pe'IaMMM JI03yttraMM 0 BOCCOe,ll;MHeHMM c 3arra,n;oM, MCJiaMCKOe rrpoIIIJioe rrpo'IHO3aKperrHJI0Ch M ITOJIY'IHJIOHOBYIO )KM3Hh 3a c'leTpeaJitt3aIJ;MM TICP cBoeH: rroJIMTMKM.

1 3p~oraH CHOBa Ha CJI]')!{6e«EpaTbeB-M)'cyJibMaH». 2016. 18 MIDI. URL: http://inosmi.ru/ politic/20160518 /2365 71848.html.

2 ,ll"oJlZOB E. B. <lleHoMeH «apa6cKott BeCHbI» 2011-2016 rr.: np11'!11HbI,pa3BH:THe, rrepcneKTHBbI I I Ty1mc, ErHneT, JlHBIDI, CHpIDI, AmKH:p: MOHorpa<l>IDI I om. p~. I1. ,ll;. 3mireJibCKIDI. M. : JIEHAH,ll;, 2017. 200 c.

111

«6onbwaa B3RTKa» HnporecTbl Ha TaKCHMe

B 2013 r. Typu;:iuo noTpHCJili cpa3y ,n;Ba KpynHhIX co6bITliH. BecHoii Ha CTaM6yJihCKOH IlJIOiu;a,n;li TaKCliM Ha'IaJiliCbMaCCOBbie npoTeCTbl npoTliB HOBOH rpa,n;ocTPOliTeJihHOH noJIM:TliKli M3plili, a B ,n;eKa6pe pa3pa3liJICH KpynHhIH KOppynu;liOHHbIH CKaH,n;aJI «EOJibIIIaH B3HTKa», pe3yJibTaTOM KOTOporo CTaJia CMeHa KaforneTa MHHliCTPOB.

B ,n;eKa6pe 2013 r. noJIM:IJ;liH apecToBana B CTaM6yne Ii AHKape 52 BhIcoKonocTaBJieHHhIX 'IliHOBHliKa,KOTOpbIX o6BM:HliJili B KOppynu;liOHHOH ,n;eHTeJibHOCTlil. Ilo MHeHlilO cne,n;CTBliH, OHM: HBJIHJiliCb nocpe,n;HM:KaMli Me)l(,ll;y npaBM:TeJibCTBOM Ii ,n;eJIOBbIM MlipOM npli pacnpe,n;eneHlili rOCKOHTpaKTOB.

IlpHMe'IaTeJihHO,'ITOo paccne,n;oBaHM:li He 3HaJI Tor,n;aIIIHliH npeMhepMliHliCTp Typu;Hli Pe,n;)l(en Taiilin 3p,n;oraH. Cpe,n;H apecToBaHHhIX 6hIJIH ChIHOBhH MliHliCTpoB BHYTPeHHHX ,n;en, 3KOHOMM:Kli, M3pa CTaM6yna, rnaBbI Hau;M:oHaJibHoro 6aHKa. Ilo,n; o6BHHeHHH nonan Ii ChIH 3p,n;oraHa He,ll;)l(MeTTliH EliJIHJib.

CKaH,n;aJI IlOBJieK 3a co6oii HapO,ll;Hbie BOJIHeHM:H: JIIO,ll;li 3ailOJIHliJili CTaM6yJihCKYIO nn01u;ap;h TaKCliM, Tpe6yH OTCTaBKli npaBHTeJihCTBa. 3p,n;oraH 6bIJI BblHJ)l(,ll;eH pacnycTliTb Ka6HHeT, O,n;HaKO Ha 3TOM KapaTeJibHhie Mepbl 3aKOH'IliJIHCb:BMeCTO HliX npeMbep CTaJI npOBO,ll;liTb MaCCOBbie 'IliCTKli B opraHax 6e3onacHoCTli. Tor,n;a )Ke OH 3aHBliJI, 'ITO«nepenoMaeT pyKH» 2 CBOHM onnoHeHTaM. EhIJIH YBOJieHbI nHTepo BhICOKonocTaBJieHHhIX coTpy,n;- HHKOB, OTBe'IalOiu;HX3a apeCTbl, B u;eJIOM )Ke no,n; COKparu;eHHe nonaJIH

1700 3

'IeJI.

Ha nepBblH B3rJIH,ll; Ka)l(eTCH, 'ITO,n;aHHOe co6bITHe HHKaK He CBH3aHO c HCJiaMliCTCKHM KypcoM IlCP, o,n;HaKo cyiu;ecTByeT pacnpocTpaHeHHOe MHeHHe 0 TOM, 'ITO3TOT CKaH,n;aJI 6hIJI HHHIJ;HHpOBaH <PeTxyJIJiaXOM flOJieHOM - JIH,n;epoM penHrH03HO-npocBeTHTeJibCKOro ,ll;BH)l(eHHH «XH3MeT»; caM OH 3TO, KaK H B pH,n;e ,n;pyrHX cnyqaeB, OTpttu;aeT.

Pa3HornacHH Me)l(,n;y 3p,n;oraHoM H fIDJieHoM CTaJIH yKpenJIHThCH nocne Toro, KaK IlOCJie,ll;HHH )l(eCTKO pacKpHTHKOBaJI pa,n;M:KaJibHbie Mepbl no pa3roHy npoTeCTYJOiu;HX Ha IlJioru;a,n;H TaKCHM Bernon 2013 r. IlpoTeCThI 6hIJIH Bbl3BaHbl HOBbIM IlJiaHOM CTpOM:TeJibCTBa B u;eHTpe CTaM6yna, KOTOpbIH npe,n;rronaran yHH'ITO)l(eHHee,n;HHCTBeHHoro B 3TOM paiioHe napKa fe3H. B OTBeT Ha KpHTHKY co CTOpOHbl flOJieHa nocne,n;oBaJIO 3aKpbITHe IIIKOJI H KypCOB, CBH3aHHbIX c rlOJieHOBCKHM ,ll;BH)l(eHHeM «XH3MeT», 'ITOIi MOrJIO Bbl3BaTb CTOJib pa,n;HKaJibHYIO peaKIJ;HIO OCHOBaTeJIH ,ll;BM:)l(eHM:H: ero BJIHHHHH 6bIJIO BilOJIHe ,ll;OCTaTO'IHO,'IT06hIopraHH30BaTb CTOJib KpynHoe KOppynu;liOHHOe pacCJie,n;oBaHHe.

1EoJibIIIaH B3RTKa. URL: http://expert.ru/2013/12/23/bolshaya-vzyatka/.

2Koppyn~HOHHbIH cKaH,n;aJI B Typ~uu: ysoJillJIHCb 3 MHHHCTpa. URL: http://www.bbc. com/russian/intemational/2013/12/13122S_turkey_ministers_resignations

3TaM JKe.

112

Bo1rnemrn Ha TaKCHMe H KOppynu;HOHHhIH CKa~a.n: CTa.JIH nOBO~OM NUI ycHJieHH.fl aBTOpHTapHOH nOJIHTHKH, npOBO~HMOH 3p~oraHOM, KOTOpa.H Haxo~HJia OTpa)l(eHHe B ~a.JihHeH:rneH: HCJiaMH3aD;HH )l(lf3HH CTpaHhI. TaK, c 2014 r. aKTHBHO CTaJIH CTPOHThC.H MeqeTH npH YHHBepcHTeTax. 060.HCH.flJIOCh 3TO )l(eJiaHHeM «~Oc~aThC.fl ~o MOJIO~e)l(H»1 H nOJIO)l(HTe..'IbHOnoBJIH-

.flTh Ha HX ~OBHOe pa3BHTHe.

KpoMe Toro, ropa3~0 CTpO)l(e CTaJia CHTyau;H.fl OTHOCHTeJihHO a6opTOB: no ~aHHhIM CTaM6yJihCKoro <l>oH~a «Mop tfaTbI», B 2015 r. JIHIIIh

3 H3 37 rocy~apcTBeHHhIX KJIHHHK npOBO~HJIH ~aHHYIO orrepau;HIO, OT-

Ka3bIBa.fl )l(eHiu;HHaM 6e3 060.HCHeHH.fl npHqHH 2. B 2013 r. 6bIJI CH.HT 3anpeT Ha HOIIIeHHe Xlf~)l(a6a pa60THHKaMH rocy~apcTBeHHhIX yqpe)l(~e­

HHH 3a HCKJIJOqeHHeM nOJIHI.l;HH H cy~oB, a 2014 r. - Ha HOIIIeHHe nJiaTKa B CTaprneH: IIIKOJie, a B 2015 r. ero pa3peIIIHJIH HOCHTh po~CTBeHHHKaM

BOeHHhIX Ha TeppHTOpHH Ka3apM H ~pyrHX BOeHHhIX o6oeKTOB3. B <l>eBpaJie 2017 r. 3anpeT 6bIJI CH.HT ~JI.fl )KeHiu;HH - o<l>Hu;epoB H KypcaHTOB

BOeHHhIX yqHJIHII.1;4.

nonblTKa nepesopo1a 2016 roAa 1r1 ee nocneACTBMH

HOBhIH BHTOK penpeCCHBHO-HCJiaMHCTCKHX Mep BHYTPH CTpaHhl HaqaJIC.fl nocJie nonhITKH rocy~apcTBeHHOro nepeBopoTa 15 HIOJI.fl 2016 r. Ero noCJie~CTBH.fl npO.HBHJIHCh BO BCex c<l>epax BHYTPeHHeH )KH3HH CTpaHbI. 3KO-

HOMHKa CTpaHhl BOIIIJia B MHTeJihHYJO peu;eCCHIO, a Hau;HOHaJihHa.fl Ba.JIIOTa yna.n:a ~o HCTOpHqecKH HH3KOro ypOBH.fl. Bo BHeIIIHHX )Ke CB.f13.flX Typu;irn HaMeTHJIC.fl eiu;e 6oJibIIIHH OTXO~ OT np03an~HOH noJIHTHKH.

l13MeHeHH.fl 3aTpbHyJIH H peJIHrH03HYJO c<l>epy. O<l>Hu;HaJihHhie BJiaCTH CTpaHbl peIIIHJIH He OTCTynaTh OT CBOHX Tpa~HI.l;HH H nocneIIIHJIH o6BH-

HHTh B opraHH3aD;HH nepesopoTa <PeTxyJIJiaxa fIOJieHa, qTo CTaJIO noBO~OM ~JI.fl HOBOH BOJIHhI «qHcTOK» B rocy~apcTBeHHhIX cTpyKTypax. Y)l(e K asry-

czy B YnpaBJieHHH no ~eJiaM peJIHrHH 6hmo ysoJieHo 2560 qeJI.s, KOTOphIX no~o3peBaJIH B CB.fl3HX c fIOJieHOM. 06Iu;ee )Ke qifCJIO yBoJieHHhIX COTPYk HHKOB ynpaBJieHH.fl npeBhICHJIO 3500 qeJI.6 TIOMHMO CJiy)Kaiu;HX ~H.flHeT, no~ COKpaiu;eHHe nonaJIH 6oJiee 8000 noJIHD;eHCKHX, 2700 pa6oTHHKOB

1 I1cJiaM H 3p,11;oratt: KaK B Typl\1111 HaBJI3bIBaIOT KOHcepBaTl1BHh!e 1\eHHOCTl1. URL: http://www.forbes.ru/mneniya/mir/331267-islam-i-erdogan-kak-v-turtsii-navyazyvayut- konservativnye-tsennosti.

2 TaM lKe.

3 Recep Tayyip Erdogan: Turkey's pugnacious president - 17 April 2017 URL: http:// www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-13746679.

4 fettrnTa6 Typl\1111 pa3pe11111JI lKeHIL\11HaM-BOeHHOCJiylKall\11M HOCl1Th x11,11;lKa6. URL: https://ria.ru/world/20170222/1488590747.html.

5 2560 personnel suspended from duty at Diyanet 9 August 2016. URL: http://www. yenisafak.com/en/news/2560-personnel-suspended-from-duty-at-diyanet-2508274.

6 TaM lKe.

113

cy,z:i;e6Hoii c11cTeMbI, 6oJiee SO BbICOKorrocTaBJieHHbIX q11HOBHHKOB1• Bcex HX o6BHHHJIH B CBH3HX c JIH,D;epoM ,ll;BHJKeHHH «X113MeT».

B KaKOM-TO CMbICJie Hey,z:i;aBIIIHHCH rrepeBopoT CTaJI oqeHb BbirO,D;eH npaBHI.Qeii rrapTHH He TOJibKO no np11q11He Toro, qTQ BOeHHbIM He y,z:i;aJIOCb CBeprHYTb rrpaBHTeJibCTBO. HapH,D;y c 3THM rrepeBOpOT CTaJI IIOBO,ll;OM ,IJ;JIH

HaqaJia HOBbIX rrpOHCJiaMCKHX H3MeHeHHH B o6I.QeCTBe. TaK, rrpH rrocryIIJieHHH Ha rocCJIYJK6y Terrepb mo6oii KaH,z:i;11,z:i;aT ,z:i;oJIJKeH rrpoxo,z:i;HTb crreIJ;HaJibHoe HHTepBblO Ha rrpHBepJKeHHOCTb H,D;eHM HCJiaMa. B xo,z:i;e rro,z:i;o6Horo HHTepBblO qenoBeKa crrpaIIIHBalOT, co6JIIO,D;aeT JIH OH IIOCT B PaMa,z:i;aH, KaK OH OTHOCHTCH K IIOIIbITKe rrepeBOpOTa B Typu;HH H r,z:i;e OH HaXO,ll;HJICH B MOMeHT BOCCTaHHH, KaKHe ra3eTbl OH q11TaeT, a TaKJKe 0 era OTHOIIIeHHH K rrpoTecTaM 2013 r.2

l13MeHeHH51 rrpOIIIJIH H B o6pa30BaTeJibHOH ccpepe, r,z:i;e B o6513aTeJibHOM rropH,z:i;Ke BBO,IJ;HTCH rrpoHCJiaMHCTCKHe pecpopMbl H ,ll;HCIJ;HIIJIHHbl.

B HOBOM IIIKOJihHOM IIJiaHe COKpaTHJIH KOJIHqecTBO qacoB Ha rrpeno,z:i;aBaHHe 11cTop1111 KeMaJIHCTCKoii Typu;m1 11 113yqeH11e JIHqHocTeii MycTacphI KeMaJIH ATaTIOpKa 11 11cMeTa l1HeH103• I1JiaH11pyeTCH noJIHOCThlO y6paTh 113 pacn11caHHH H3yqeHHe TeopHH 3BOJIIOIJ;HH H paCIIIHpHTb npeno,z:i;aBaHHe OCHOB HCJiaMa: HanpHMep, npe,z:i;noJiaraeTCH paccKa3bIBaTb ,z:i;eTHM o ,D;JKHxa,z:i;e4.

KpoMe Toro, I1pe311,z:i;eHT Typu;1111 Pe,z:i;JKen Tai111n 3p,z:i;oraH B oKrn6pe

2016 r. 3a51BHJI 0 B03MOJKHOM B03BpaTe B CTpaHe CMepTHOH Ka3HH. OH OTMeTHJI, qTo BblCTYilHT c TaKOH HHHIJ;HaTHBOH nepe,z:i; ,z:i;enYTaTaMH BeJIHKOrO HaIJ;HOHaJihHOro co6paHHH CTpaHhl, a B CJiyqae o,z:i;o6peHH51 ,z:i;aHHoro 3aKOHOnpoeKTa HenpeMeHHO era paT11cp11u;11pyeT5• TipH 3TOM BepXOBHbIH rrpe,z:i;- CTaBHTeJib EBpOCOI03a no HHOCTpaHHbIM ,z:i;enaM H IlOJIHTHKe 6e3onaCHOCTH ct>e,z:i;ep11Ka MorepHHH 3aHBHJia, qTo B TaKOM cJiyqae Typu;HH MOJKeT 3a6b1Tb o BCrynJieHHH B EC6, qTo 11 caM 3p,z:i;oraH npeKpacHo noHHMaeT 6e3 ee noHcHeHHH.

B OTBeT Ha KpHTHKY 3p,z:i;oraH no,z:i;qepKHyJI: «CillA, 51noHHH, K11Taii HMelOT no,z:i;o6Hy10 npou;e,z:i;ypy. EcJIH JIIO,IJ;H peIIIaT BepHYTh ee, H YBepeH,

1President Erdogan could be using the coup against him to turn Turkey towards fullscale Islamisation. URL: http:I/www.independent.co. uk/news/world/europe/turkey-coup- president-erdogan-islam-akp-government-a7142836.html.

2Turkey's 'devout generation' project means lost jobs, schools for many 13 October 2016. URL: http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/originals/2016/10/turkey-post-putsch-crackdown- transform-education.html. #ixzz4N2zqQxrS.

3Turkey's new curriculum: More Erdogan, more Islam. URL: http://www.politico.eu/ article/erdogan-turkey-education-news-coup-analysis-curriculum-history-istanbul/.

4TaM )Ke.

5Erdogan announces Turkish parliament will consider bringing back the death penalty. URL: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/turkey-death-penalty-erdogan- reintroduce-debate-consider-turkish-parliament-a7386591.html.

6B EC rrpoKOMMeHTHposa.1n1 rrnaHhI Typl\HH sepHYTh cMepTHyro Ka3Hh. URL: http:// www.rbc.ru/politics/18/07/2016/578cb2899a7947e4ee65870S?from=main.

114

'ITOIIOJIHTH'leCKHerrapTHH HCIIOJIJUIT 3T}'rrpoch6y»1, IlbITa5ICb HaMeKHYTh Ha rrpe,n;B3HTOe OTHOIIleHHe EBpOIIhI, a TaIOKe Ha TO, 'ITOB mo60M CJIY'lae BOIIpOCbI y EC B03HHKHYT TOJibKO K Typu;HH.

TaKHM o6pa3oM, rrorrhITKa rrepeBopoTa rrpo,n;eMOHCTpHpOBaJia ,n;Be BruKHhre TeH,n;eHD;HM B TYPeu;KoM o6ru;ecTBe.

Bo-nepBbLX, peJIMrM03Hhre o6ne,n;MHeHMH rro-rrpe)l{HeMy 11rparoT KJIIO'le-

Byro poJib B rroJIMTMKe Typeu;Koi1 Pecrry6JIMKM. TioCJie,n;oBaBIIlMe MaccoBhre YBOJibHeHMH B cy,n;ax, IIOJIMll;MM, ccpepe o6pa30BaHMH H ~HaJIMCTMKM IIOKa-

3bIBalOT, 'ITOrrpHBep)l{eHD;bI ,lJ;)l{aMaaTOB rrpMCYTCTBYIOT BO Bcex Ba)l{HbIX HMIIlaX M 'ITOno,n;o6HaH ceTh MO)l{eT npe,n;cTaBJIHTb peaJihHYIO yrp03y ,n;JIH BJiaCTM 3p,n;oraHa.

Bo-BmopbLX, MIOJihCKMH nepeBopoT He npe,n;oTBpaTHJI MCJiaMCKHX HaCTpoeHHH zypeu;Koro PYKOBO,D;CTBa, Ha 'ITO,BepoHTHO, pacc'IMTbIBaJIMnYTlJHCThI, a TOJihKO YKpenHJI Mx, HarJIH,n;HO npo,n;eMoHcTpHpoBaB Hapo,n;y, ,n;o qero MO)l{eT ,n;oBeCTM ,n;eMoKpaTMH B rocy,n;apcTBeHHhIX CTPYKTYPax, B TOM 'IMCJie MB apMMM.

KpoMe 3Toro, nepeBopoT M MaccoBbie «'IHCTKM», npoBe,n;eHHhre BCJie,n; 3a HHM, OKOH'laTeJibHOOT,D;aJIHJIM Typu;HIO OT 3arra,n;a. EoJiee Toro, Bee ,n;eH:- CTBMH Typeu;KMX BJiaCTeH M 3aHBJieHMH rrpe3H,D;eHTa CTpaHbl IIOKa3bIBalOT, 'ITOB ,n;aJihHei1llleM H3MeHeHMH BHYTpMnOJIMTM'lecKoroKypca He rrpe,n;BH- ,D;HTCH.

***

Ha npoTH)l{eHMM rnoero npaBJieHHH TICP npoBO,D;MJia nocJie,n;oBaTeJihHyro BHYTpeHHIOIO nOJIHTMKY, nocTerreHHO ycHJIHBa5I rrpHCYTCTBHe peJIHrMH B )l{H3HM CTpaHhI Ha ocpMu;HaJibHOM ypOBHe. HOBbie M3MeHeHHH B KOHCTHT}'- ll;MM 2017 r. ,n;aJIH npe3M,n;eHT}'CTpaHbl eru;e 60Jibllle B03MO)l{HOCTei1 H pbI'laroB ,n;JIH npo,n;OJI)l{eHMH ,n;aHHOro KypCa.

Typeu;KHH nOJIHTOJIOr OcMaH 3CKM,n;)l{H0rJIY B CBOeH KHHre «Tipe3M,n;eHTCKaH pecny6JIHKa M MCJiaM» nMCaJI, 'ITOB CJiyqae no,n;,n;ep)l{KM H3MeHeHHH Ha pecpepeH,n;yMe Typu;HH 6y,n;eT ,n;BHraTbCH no JIMHMM noJIHoH: MCJiaM113all;MH CTpaHhr2. I1cxo,n;H H3 Toro, 'ITOnpoHCXO,D;HT Ha npaKTMKe, aBTOp KHMrM He onrn6rn: HCJiaMH3au;MH Typu;1111 ,n;eH:cTBHTeJihHO npo,n;OJI)l{aeTCH, npM'leM no BCeM HanpaBJieHMHM.

c O,D;HOH CTOpOHbl, BOCTO'IHOHTypu;HH xopolllO 3HaKOMbl HCJiaMCKMe npHHD;HnhI H u;eHHOCTH, H eCTb Te, KTO COBCeM He npOTHB BepHyThCH K nopH,n;KaM npOIIIJibIX JieT H ,n;a)l{e CTOJieTHH.

C ,n;pyroH: cTopoHhI, Typu;11H no'ITMcTo JieT cJie,n;yeT rrp11Hu;11naM ATa-

TIOpKa M HBJIHeTCH O,D;HOH H3 caMbIX eBponeH3HpOBaHHbIX CTpaH BocTOKa, n03TOMY 'laCTbJIIO,n;eH: BCephe3 onacalOTCH npo,n;JieHMH npOHCJiaMCKOrO KypCa, K KOTopoMy TYPeu;Koe o6ru;ecTBO He roToBo.

1 Turkey coup: President Erdogan backs reintroduction of death penalty. URL: http:/I www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/turkey-death-penalty-erdogan-coup-president- backs-capital-punishment-a7178371.html.

2 How Islamic will Erdogan's presidential system be? URL: http://www.al-monitor.com/ pulse/originals/2016/12/turkey-islamic-erdogans-presidential-system-will-be.html.

115

HarrpHMep, MHOrHe :>KeHiu;HHhI 6oJITCR rrpecJieAOBaHHH 3a KopoTKHe ITJiaThJil, a M)':>K'IHHhl,KOTOpbie He co6moAalOT ITOCT B PaM~aH, He CMO- ryr IlO.JIY'IHThpa6ory2. CpeAH rroJIHTHtiecKHx CHJI TaK:>Ke ecTh HecornacHb1e c HOBOH rroJIHTHKOH TICP - HapOAHO-pecrry6JIHKaHcKaJI rrapTHJI H ,l(eMoKpaTH'leCKaJInapTHJI HapOAOB, BbICTyrraIOiu;He 3a coxpaHeHHe TpaAHD;H- OHHOH cHcTeMhI c CHJihHhIM rrapJiaMeHTOM. B HaCTOJiiu;ee BpeMJI HaceJieHHe Typeu;KoH: Pecrry6JIHKH ocTaeTrn tieTKO pa3AeJieHHhIM Ha ABa JiarepH: MOAepHHCTOB H KOHCepBaTOpOB.

1President Erdogan could be using the coup against him to turn Turkey towards full-scale Islamisation 18 July 2016. URL: http://www.independent.eo.uk/news/world/europe/turkey- coup-president-erdogan-islam-akp-government-a7142836.html.

2Turkey's 'devout generation' project means lost jobs, schools for many 13 October 2016. URL: http://wwvv.al-monitor.com/pulse/originals/2016/10/turkey-post-putsch-crackdown- transform-education.html. #ixzz4ZF4z0a1C.

fnaBa 7

OC06EHHOCTM 3KOHOMM"IECKOfO PA3BMTMH

TYPEUKOM PECnY6nMKM

B 2016-2018 rr. 3KOHOMHKa Typeu;Kott Pecrry6JIHKH Haxo,n;HJiach B KpH3HCHOM COCTOHHHH. Bo MHOrOM TaKOH rrpou;ecc Hepa3phIBHO CBH3aH c BHeIIIHett IIOJIHTHKOH Typu;HH: IIOXOJIO,ll;aHHe pOCCHHCKO-rypeu;KHX OTHOIIIeHHH H HaJIO)KeHHe rrpo,n;OBOJlhCTBeHHOro 3M6apro Ha KpyrrHettIIIHe CTaThH TYPeu;Koro 3KcrropTa pocrn:HcKo:H cTopoHo:H <i_>aKTwi:ecKH 3aKphVIH ,n;AA Typ- u;1111 O,ll;HH H3 caMhIX BhirO,ll;HhIX H KpyrrHhIX phIHKOB c6hITa. KpH3HC B OTHOrneHHHX c 3arra,n;oM H BBe,n;eHHe caHKIJ;HH rrpOTHB AHKaphI TaKme OTpa3HJIHCh Ha TeMrrax 3KOHOMH'i:ecKoropocTa rocy,n;apcTBa.

3a KOpOTKHH cpoK B CTpaHe o6BaJIHJiaCh BaJIIOTa, 6Hp)KeBhie KOTHpOBKH Typeu;KHX KOMrraHHtt CHJihHO orrycTHJIHCh. KpoMe 3Toro, Typu;HH rroTepHJia 60JihIIIOe KOJIHqecTBO 3apy6e)KHhlX HHBeCTOpOB, a Kpe,n;HTHhIH pettTHHr CTpaHhl orrycTHJICH ,n;o «MycopHoro» ypOBHH. c rro,n;o6HhIMH rrpo6JieMaMH Typu;HH yme CTaJIKHBaJiaCh B 2001 r., Kor,n;a B CTpaHe IIO,ll; BJIHHHHeM ,n;eBaJihBau;HH BaJIIOThl HaqaJICH 3KOHOMHqecKHH KpH3HC.

.Z:Vrn Toro, qT06hI IlOHHTh, rroqeMy Typu;HH OKa3aJiaCh B TaKOM IIOJIO)KeHHH M KaK OHa MO)KeT BhIHTM H3 Hero, Heo6xo,n;HMO BhlHBHTh OCHOBHhie TeH,n;eHu;HH B Typeu;Ko:H 3KOHOMHKe, a TaKme rrpoCJie,n;HTh ITYTh ee pa3BHTHH c 1990-x rr., Kor,n;a B CTpaHe OKOHqaTeJihHO c<i_>opMHpOBaJiaCh phlHOqHaH CHCTeMa.

nM6epamt3a'-'•UI3KOHOMMKM B1980-1990-e rOAbl

CoBpeMeHHYJO 3KOHOMHKY Typu;HH CJie,n;yeT H3yqaTh c KoHu;a XX B., Kor,n;a B 1983 r. K BJiaCTH rrpHIIIeJI TypfYT 03aJI. C ero rrpHxo,n;oM B Typu;HH HaqaJICH rrpou;ecc JIH6epaJIH3au;HH 3KOHOMHKH. B CTPaHe rn11p0Ko rrpoBo,n;HJiach rrpHBaTH3au;HH rocy,n;apcrneHHhIX rrpe,n;rrpHHTHH, a OCHOBHOH 3KOHOMHqecKOH H,n;ee:H cTaJio cBo6o,n;Hoe phrnoqHoe pa3BHTHe.

TaKHe ,n;e:HcTBHH 3Haq11TeJihHO ITOBhICHJIH rrpHBJieKaTeJihHOCTh Typu;HH ,ll;JIH HHOCTpaHHOro KaIIHTaJia: B 1980 r. B Typeu;KYJO 3KOHOMHKY 6bLJIO BJIO- )KeHO 229 MJIH ,ll;OJIJI., B 1990 r. - yme 1,3 MJip,11; ,ll;OJIJI., a B 1997 CTpaHa rrpHBJieKJia 6,4 MJip,11; ,ll;OJIJI. rrpHMhIX HHBeCTHIJ;Httl.

1 Ea6aeBa C. Typeu;K11H Maprn K pbmoqttoH: 3KOHOM!1Ke 11 IfasecnUI. 1999. 10 liJOJIB. C. 4.

117

PocT o6'heMaHHBeCTHQHH IIOBJieK 3a co6oii H pOCT 3KOHOMHKH. 3a HCKJUOqeHHeM 1991 r., Kor,n;a Haqano BOHHhI B flepcH,n;CKOM 3aJIHBe yxy,n;rnwm 3KOHOM11:qeceyro c11:zyaQHIO B perHoHe, l'ypQHRrroKa3hrnana y6e,n;HTeJibHhie TeMnhI pocTa BIIJIOTb ,n;o 1994 r.: 9 % B 1990 r., 6,4 % B 1992 r. H 8,1 %

B 1993 r.

0,n;HaKO CTa6HJibHble TeMIIbI 3KOHOMHqecKoro poCTa conpoBO)K,ll;aJIHCb ern;e 6011bI1IHMH TeMnaMH pocTa HH<l>AAQHH. Bb16paHHbIH TYPeQKHMH BJiaCTRMH B 1980-e rr. nYTh 1111:6epan11:3aQHH 3KOHOMHKH npe,n;no11aran pa3BHTHe 3KCIIOpTHO opHeHTHpOBaHHblX OTpaCJieH. 0,n;HaKO B TOT MOMeHT TypeQKaR Pecny6JIHKa He HMeJia HH BblCOKHX TeXHOJIOrHH, HH HHHOBaQHOHHOro rrpOH3BO,IJ;CTBa, no np11:q11:He qero 6bIJIO perneHO IIOBbIIIIaTb KOHKypeHTOcrroco6HOCTb ToBapoB nYTeM rrocTORHHOH ,n;eBaJibBaQHH HaQHOHaJibHOH BaJIIOTbl ,IJ;JIR 6011ee BbirO,IJ;HOro 3KCIIOpTa.

TaKHM o6pa30M, HH<l>JIRQHR B KOHQe 1980-x rr. Haxo,n;HJiaCb Ha ypOBHe 30-40 %, qTo RBJI.R:eTCR oqeHb BbICOKHM noKa3aTeJieM, oco6eHHO ,IJ;JIR TaKOH CTpaHbI, KaK TypQHR. PoCT HH<l>AAQHH KOHTpo1111:poBaJICR npaBHTeJibCTBOM, O,n;HaKO ,n;eJiaTb 3TO CTaHOBHJIOCb BCe CJIO)KHee.

CTHMYJIHPYIOrn;aR <P11:cKaJibHM rroJIHTHKa, rrpoBO,ll;HMaR rocy,n;apcTBOM, rrpe,n;no11ara11a yBe1111qeHHe peaJihHOH 3apa6oTHOH rr11aTbI 3a cqeT pocTa rocy,n;apCTBeHHbIX pacxo,n;oB. B pe3yJihTaTe no,n;o6ttoii rroJIHTHKH Haqa11rn poCT .n;e<l>HQH:Ta roc610,n;)KeTa, KOTOpbIH B 1993 r. COCTaBHJI 6,7 % BaJIOBOro HaQHOHaJibHOro rrpO,ll;yKTa1.

JVrn noKpbITHR ,n;e<PHQH:Ta npaBHTeJlbCTBO pernIDIO np11:6erHYTb K BHeIIIHHM 3aifMaM, KOTOpbie ,IJ;OJl)KHbl 6bIJIH rrpOBO,IJ;HTbCH qepe3 6aHKOBCKYIO CHCTeMy nYTeM BbIKyrra roco61111:raQHH. ,ll;OJIR BbIIIJiaT no 3aHMaM nOCTOHHHO poCJia, H rocy,n;apCTBO npHHRJIO peIIIeHHe CHH3HTb ,IJ;OXO,IJ;HOCTb no roc6YMaraM, qTo MOMeHTaJlbHO IIOHH3HJIO rrpHBJieKaTeJibHOCTb HaQHOHaJibHbIX QeHHbIX 6yMar. ¥fa-3a 3TOro HHOCTpaHHbIH KaIIHTaJI HaqaJI nOKH,n;aTb TypQHIO, qTo ern;e CHJibHee o6BaJIHJIO TYPeQKy10 1111:py: B 1994 r. ee na,n;eHHe K ,ll;OJIJiapy COCTaBHJIO 170 %.

OcJIO)KHRJia c11:zyaQ1110 H noJIHTHqecKaR ttecTa6HJibHOCTb. B 1990-x rr. KpH3HC KOCHYJICH q11:HOBHHqbero arrnapaTa 11 oco6etttto qeTKO Bbipa)KaJicR B 6hICTpOH CMeH.R:eMOCTH ,IJ;OJI)KHOCTHbIX JIHQ.

B 1993 r. rrpeMbep-MHHHCTpoM CTaJia TaHcy l.fHJIJiep, rroJIHTHKa KOTopoii 6b111a npe11:Myrn;ecTBeHHO HaQeJieHa Ha c611H)Kett11e c EBporroii. B 1996 r. H3-3a o6BHHeHHH B KoppyrrQHH l.fH1111ep no,n;a11a B OTCTaBKy, a ee MecTo 3aHRJI MecYT HbIJIMa3, o,n;HaKo rrpo6bIJI B ,n;oJI)KHOCTH Bcero 4 MeC.R:Qa. Ha cMeHy eMy rrpHrne11 rrpoHcJiaMCKH HacTpoeHHbIH JIH,n;ep riapTHH 611aro-

.n;ettcTBHH He,n;)KMeTTHH 3p6aKaH. flpoBO,IJ;HMM HM rroJIHTHKa He ycTpoIDia BOeHHbIX, KOTOpbie B 1997 r. IIOTpe6oBaJIH OT npaBHTeJibCTBa BbIIIOJIHeHHR MeMopatt.n;YMa H3 18 nyHKTOB ,IJ;JIR CTa6HJIH3aQHH CHTYaQHH.

1 R.T. Prime Ministry Undersecretariat of Treasury. General Directorate of economic research. Selected economic indicators. 1998.

118

3p6aKaH yrne.n B OTCTaBI<y, KpeCJio BHOBb 3aIDUI Mecyr HbIJIMa3. B KoHu;e 1998 r. rrpaB11TeJibCTBY 6bIJI BbrneceH BOTyM He,n;oBepIDI, 11 MbIJIMa3 rroK11HYJI IIOCT rrpeMbepa. Ilo,n;o6HOrO po,n;a c11ryau;ID1 He MOrJia He OTpa311TbCJI Ha 3KOHOM11qecKo:H o6cTaHOBKe: y BJiaCTHbIX KpyroB Typu;1111 He 6b1JI0 e,n;11Horo IlJiaHa no rrpeo,n;oJieH11IO 3KOHOM11qecKOH CTarHau;1111, Ka:>K,ll;bIH 113 BHOBb BCTYfiaBIIIHX B ,ll;OJl)KHOCTb CTapaJICR peIII11Tb npo6JieMy TaK, KaK 6bIJIO BblrO,D;HO eMY, HJI11 )Ke He CTapaJICR B0061Qe.

3KOHOMM'teCKMHKpM3MC 2001 roAa. Poer 3KOHOMMKM 2002-2007 rOAbl

Me)K,ll;yttapo,n;HbIH BaJIIOTHbIH <PoH,D; B 1996 r. npe,n;yrrpe,n;HJI 061QeCTBeHHOCTb 0 Ha,D;B11ra101QeMCH 3KOHOMlfqecKOM Kp11311Ce B Typu;1111. 3TO coo61QeH11e 3aCTaBHJIO MHOr11x lfHOCTpaHHblX 11HBeCTOpOB 3a,n;YMaTbC.fl Ha,n; BbIBO- ,ll;OM cpe,n;crn 113 rrpo6JieMHOH 3KOHOM11K111.

K HaqaJiy 2000-x rr. 113 Typeu;Ko:H 3KOHOM11K11 6bIJIO Bhrne,n;eHo 6oJiee 70 MJip,n; ,ll;OJIJI. 3aKpbITb no,n;o6HbIH ,n;e<P11u;11T Typeu;Koe rrpaB11TeJibCTBO 11 MeCTHhie 6aHK11 6hIJI11 He B cocTORH1111. B 1998 r. Typu;11R 11 MB<P rro,n;rr11caJI11 corJia111eH11e, B COOTBeTCTB1111 c KOTOpbIM rrpe,n;cTaB11TeJI11 opraH113a- u;1111 BeJI11 Ha6JIIO,D;aTeJibHyIO ,n;e.R:TeJlbHOCTb 3a TypeQKOH 3KOHOM11KOH.

B HOR6pe 2000 r. MB<P Bh1,n;eJI11JI 6oJiee 11 MJip,n; ,n;OJIJI.2 Kpe,n;11ToB ,n;JIR CTa611JI113au;1111 3KOHOM11K11, o,n;HaKO Kap,n;11HaJibHO c11ryau;11R He IIOMeH.fl-

JiaCb. 19 <PeBpaJIR 2001 r. Ha 3ace,n;aH1111 CoBeTa 6e3orracHocT11 Typu;1111 B xo,n;e o6c~,n;eHIDI perneHIDI CJIO)K11BIII11XCJI rrpo6JieM rrpaB11TeJibCTBY 6bIJIO

rrpe,n;JIO)KeHo yH:T11 B oTcTaBKy. Tor,n;a rrpeMbep-M11H11cTp Typu;1111 E10JieHT 3,n;)KeB11T BbICTYfiHJI c pe3KOH Kp11T11Kott ,n;e:HcTB11H rrpe3M,n;eHTa AxMeTa He,n;- )K,ll;eTa Ce3epa.

3ace,n;aH11e 3aKoHqHJIQCb CKaH,D;aJIOM, KOTOpbIH CTaJI IIOCJie,n;HeH CTyrreHblO Ha rryTM K Ha3peBaBIIIeMy 3KOHOM11qecKOMY Kp11311Cy. 3a O,ll;11H ,n;eHb JI11pa ynaJia 6oJiee qeM Ha 3000 %, ,l.l;OCT11rHyB OTMeTK11 B 1,5 MJIH 3a ,ll;OJlJiap3. l.J.aCTHbie 6aHK11 B CBOIO oqepe,n;b 3aH11MaJI11Cb crreeyJIRT11BHbIM11 orrepau;IDIM11. QeHTpo6aHK rroTPaTHJI 6oJiee 5 MJ1p,n; ,n;oJIJI. 113 pe3epBOB Ha crn611JI113au;1110 IIOJIO)KeH11.fl, o,n;HaKO 3TO He rrp11HeCJIO pe3yJibTaTOB. B 11TOre 6bIJIO o6'bRBJieHO0 rrepexo,n;e K IIJiaBaIOIQeMy KypCY BaJIIOTbl.

Bee 3T11 co6b1T11R rrpe,n;Be1QaJI11 CHJibHe:Hrnee 3KOHOM11qecKoe rra,n;eH11e rro,n; CTaTb TOMy, KOTOpoe Typu;11.fl rrepe)KHJia B Kp11311CHOM 2001 r. C11rya- u;1110 He 11crrpaBHJia ,n;a)Ke rro,n;,n;ep)KKa MB<P 11 <PopM11poBaH11e aHT11Kp11311c-

1 Fatih Ozatay, Giiven Sak. The 2000-2001 financial crisis in Turkey Central Bank of Turkey and Ankara University. August 2002 (revised). URL: https://www.researchgate.net/ publication/242034963_THE_2000-2001_FINANCIAL_CRISIS_IN_TURKEY.

2 IMF agrees Turkish loans 6 December, 2000. URL: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/ business/1057382.stm.

3 A. Erinc; Yeldan. Behind the 2000/2001 Turkish crisis: Stability, Credibility, and Governance, for Whom? Bilkent University Department of Economics, p. 178. URL: http:// yeldane.bilkent.edu. tr/Chennai_yeldan2002. pdf.

119

HOH nporpaMMhI - K 2001 r. BBn ynaJI Ha 5,6 % 1• EhICTpbIMH TeMnaMH poCJia 6e3pa6oTm:i;a, KOTOpaH K Haqany 2002 r. ,ll;OCTHrJia OTMeTKH 10,4 %2.

B 6oph6e c ee pocTOM He noMor ,ll;Cl)Ke ITJiaH MB<I>: HecMOTPH Ha 3HaqHTeJihHoe pa3BHTHe 3KOHOMHKH B IJ;eJIOM, 6e3pa6oTHIJ;a OCTaBaJiaCb CTa6HJibHO BbICOKOH (Ta6JI. 2).

3,n;ech CJie,n;yeT OTMeTHTb, qTo BbICOKaH 6e3pa6oTHIJ;a- o,n;Ha H3 OTJIHqHTeJibHbIX qepT rypeIJ;KOH 3KOHOMHKH. Ha COCTOHHHH 6e3pa60THIJ;bl (pHC. 3)

CKa3bIBaeTCH cpa3y HeCKOJibKO cpaKTOpOB.

15

13

11

9

Bo-nepBblX, 6oJihIIIYJO poJih HrpaeT o6u:i;Hii HH3KHH ypoBeHb o6pa3oBaHHH, oco6eHHO cpe,n;H 6e,n;Horo HaceJieHHH. HecMOTpH Ha o6pa3oBaTeJibHhie pecpopMbI, JIIO,ll;H no-npe:>KHeMy OCTalOTCH HeKBaJIHcpHIJ;HpOBaHHblMH pa6oqHMH, BCJie,n;CTBHe qero HMelOT npo6JieMbI c Tpy,n;oycTpOHCTBOM.

I Koen Brinke. The Turkish 2000-01 banking crisis. URL: https://economics.rabobank. com/publications/2013 / september/the-turkish-2000-01-banking-crisis/.

2 TaM lKe.

120