Vnutrennyaya_politika_Turtsii_2002-2018

H3BO,ZJ;CTBa. Cero,n;mi: B TypQHH ycrreurno ocyIQeCTBJUieT CBOIO ,n;e.sITeJihHOCTb p.!I,D; KOMIIaHHH, 3aHHMalOIQHXC.!I BbIIIYCKOM o6'beKTOBBOeHHOH rrpoMhIIIIJieHHOCTH. KpynHeH:rrmMH rocy,n;apCTBeHHhIMH KOMrraHH.!IMH .!IBJI.!IIOTC.!I: MKEK, ASELSAN, ROKETSAN, OTOKAR, TAPASAN, HAVELSAN, ASPILSAN, TUBiTAK, TU~A~, STM, MiKES, EHSiM, HTR H ,n;pyme. HeMaJI0Ba:>1rnyro pOJib B pa3BHTHH BOeHHoro rrpOH3BO,ZJ;CTBa HrpaeT H qacTHbIH ceKTOp.

B Harrm ,ZJ;HH TypQH.!I oco6o rrpeycrreJia B H3rOTOBJieHHH Boopy:>KeHHH, rrpe,n;Ha3HaqeHHhIX ,ZJ;JI.!I cyxorrYTHhIX BOHCK, B qacTHOCTH 6poHeMarrmH1 H orHeCTpeJibHoro OPY:>KH.!!2, rrpoH3BO,ZJ;CTBO KOTOpbIX HarrpaBJieHHO He TOJibKO Ha ycoBeprneHCTBOBaHHe co6CTBeHHOH apMHH, HO If Ha 3cpcpeKTHBHOe HMIIOpT03aMeIQeHHe.

HarrpHMep, IIITYPMOBaJI BHHTOBKa MPT-76, KOTOpa.!I 3HaqHTeJihHO rrpeBocxo,n;HT 3apy6e:>KHbIX rrpOH3BO,ZJ;HTeJieH: no TeXHifqecKHM xapaKTepHCTHKaM3'BbITeCHHJia c OpY:>KeHHOro pbIHKa HeMeQKHe BHHTOBKH MapKH Heckler

& Koch4.

KpoMe 3Toro, TypQH.!I cerO,ZJ;H.!I HrpaeT poJib IIOCTaBIQHKa CBOeH: BOeHHOH rrpo,n;yKQHH B PM cTpaH. JlH,ZJ;HPYJOIQHe MeCTa B ,n;aHHOH OTpacJIH 3aHHMaIOT KOMIIaHHH OTOKAR H FNSS, rrpoH3BOMIQHe 6poHeMaIIIHHbI cepHH ARMA

If PARSS.

XoT.!I TypQH.!I .!IBJI.!IeTC.!I rocy,n;apcTBOM, KOTopoe rrpaKTifqecKH co Bcex CTOpOH OKpY:>KeHO MOp.!IMH, ee BOeHHO-MOpCKOH cpJIOT yKOMIIJieKTOBaH TexHHKOH 3apy6e:>KHoro rrpoH3BO,ZJ;CTBa (B ocHOBHOM CllIA H <PpaHQHH), xorn HeKOTOpbie co6CTBeHHbie pa3pa6oTKH TaK:>Ke HMelOTC.!I If B 6oJiblllHHCTBe CBOeM rrpe,n;CTaBJieHhI KOMrram-1ei1 DEARSAN6.

qTO KacaeTC.!I BOeHHO-B03,ZJ;YIIIHbIX CHJI, TO IIOKa caMOCTO.!ITeJibHO TypQH.!I rrpOH3BO,ZJ;HT TOJibKO 6eCIIHJIOTHHKH7 If MO,n;epHH3HpyeT HTaJib.!IHCKHe BepToJieThI T-129 ATAKB. B cpe,n;HecpoqHoH rrepcrreKTHBe TypQH.!I rrJiaHHpyeT BbIIIYCK co6cTBeHHblX caMOJieToB9 If y:>Ke rrpe,n;rroJiaraeT, KaKHe H3 HHX 6y,ZJ;YT B CKOpOM BpeMeHH rrpHH.!ITbl Ha BOOpy:>KeHHe. Cpe,n;H HHX

1 focy,'\apcTBEHH<UI BOEHHO-I1p0Mb!IIIJIEHH<UI KOMrramrn. URL: https://www.otokar.com. tr/tr-tr/urunler/Sayfalar/Savunma-Sanayii. aspx.

2TaM JKe.

3Milli Piyade Tiifegimiz MPT-76 ozellikleri 08 Nisan 2016. URL: http://www.haberturk. com/gundem/haber/1221859-mpt -76-ozellikleri.

4focy,'\apCTBEHH<UI BOEHHO-IlpOMbIIIIJIEHH<UI KOMITamrn:. URL: https:/ /www.otokar.com. tr/tr-tr/urunler/Sayfalar/Savunma-Sanayii.aspx.

5Pars ve Arma Tiirkiye'den diinyaya a<;1hyor. URL: http://www.niksardanismend.com/ video/5/pars-ve-arma-turkiyeden-dunyaya-aciliyor.html.

6focy,'\apCTBEHH<UI BOEHHO-I1p0Mb!IIIJIEHH<UI KOMITamrn. URL: https://www.otokar.com. tr/tr-tr/urunler/Sayfalar/Savunma-Sanayii. aspx.

7Yeni nesil ANKA ba§anyla u<;tu 30 Ocak 2015. URL: http://www.milliyet.eom.tr/yeni- nesil-anka-basariyla-uctu/ekonomi/detay/2006471/default.htm.

8BoeHHaH :rnu;uKJIOITEl'\l!H. URL: http:/ /www.militaryfactory.com/aircraft/detail. asp? aircraft_id = 1011.

9CoseT o6opoHHOH rrpoMbIIIIJieHHOCTl! Typu;uu. URL: http://www.ssm.gov.tr/home/ institutional/Documents/Sp2012_2016/index.html.

91

yqe6HbIH caMoJieT caMoJieT TUSA$ Hiirku§1 11 11cTpe611TeJib TAI TFX2, KoTOpb1e ,ZJ;OJI:>KHbI rrorroJIHl1Tb BBC Typeu;KoH Pecrry6JI11K11 K 2018 11 2023 rr. COOTBeTCTBeHHO.

HerrpocTo o6cTOl1T ,a;eJio c c11cTeMOH rrpoT11BOB03,ll;yurnoii o6opoHbI. l'yp-

1.l;llil y:>Ke Ha rrpOTH:>KeHl111 ,ll;OJirl1X JieT IlbITaeTCH rrp1106peCTl1 Cl1CTeMbl IlBO, KOTOpbIX caMa He 11p0113BO,ll;l1T. B 2007 r. 3TO :>KeJiaH11e rrepepoCJIO B aKTl1BHbie ,n;eHCTBIDI: Typeu;KM Pecrry6JI11Ka 11H11u;1111poBaJia TeH,ll;ep Ha IIOKYIIKy Cl1CTeM rrpOTl1BOB03,ZJ;YIIIHOH o6opOHbl, B KOTOpOM yqaCTBOBaJI11 POCCl1H, K11rnH, CIIIA 11 KOHcopu;11YM eBporreiicK11x KOMrraH11H Eurosam3.

IloCJie rneCTl1 JieT KOHKypeHTHOH 6opb6bI Typu;11H OT,ZJ;aBaJia rrpe,n;rroqTeHl1e pOCCl1HCKOMY 11 KHTaHCKOMy rrp0113BO,ZJ;l1TeJIHM, qTo, O,ZJ;HaKO, BCTpeTHJIO rrpoT11Bo,n;eiicTB11e HATO, rrpe,n;CTaB11TeJI11 KOTopoii 06'bHCH11JI113TO HecoBMeCTl1MOCTbIO Cl1CTeM IlBO, KOTOpbie :>KeJiaeT rrp1106peCTl1 Typl.l;llil, C aHaJIOr11qHblMl1 Cl1CTeMaMl1 opraHl13au;11114.

HecMOTpH Ha 3To, B 2013 r. rro6e,n;y B TeH,ll;epe o,n;ep:>KaJI KHrnii, o,n;HaKo CIIIA He MorJI11 ,n;orrycTl1Tb, qT06b1 y rrapTHepa no HATO Ha BOOpy:>KeH1111 HaXO,ZJ;HJiaCb O,ZJ;Ha 113 MOII.l;HeHllll1X Cl1CTeM IlBO ero KOHKypeHTa, 1103TOMy rrepe11IJI11 K rnaHTa:>KY. B OTBeT Ha HaMepeHl1H 1'ypu;1111rrp1106peCTl1 Cl1CTeMbl nBO CIIIA rrpe,n;yrrpe,n;11JI11 0 npeKpaII.1;eHl111 rrp0113BO,ll;CTBa BepToJieTOB T-70 Black Hawk 1111cTpe611TeJIH F-35, pe3yJihTaTe qero Typu;IDI, He OTJI11qaIOII.1;aHcH rrp0113BO,ll;CTBOM BOeHHO-B03,ll;YllIHOH TeXHl1Kl1, 6bma BbIHY:>K,ZJ;eHa OTKa3aTbCH OT BbirO,ll;HOH C,ll;eJIKl15 •

Cero,n;HH Typu;11H, KOTopaH Haxo,n;11TCH B HerrpocTbIX BHernHe110JI11T11qecK11x OTHOllleH11HX co CTpaHaMl1 3arra,n;a, BHOBb 3a,n;yMaJiaCb 0 Heo6xo,n;11MOCTl1 110110JIHeHl1H CB011X BOOpy)KeHl1H Cl1CTeMaMl1 IlBO, O,ZJ;HaKO B 3TOT pa3 ocTaHOB11Jia CBOH Bb16op Ha TexHoJior11Hx pocc11iicKoro rrpo113Bo,n;- cTBa.

I13BeCTHO, qTo Typu;11H Bb1pa311.Jia roTOBHOCTb rrp1106pecT11 y Pocc1111 c11cTeMy rrpOTl1BOB03,n;yrnHoi1 11 rrpoT11BopaKeTHOH o6opoHbI C-400 «Tp11yMcp» 3a 2,5 MJip,n; ,n;oJIJI. 11, 6oJiee Toro, c,n;eJiaJia 3arrpoc Ha rrepe,n;a- qy TeXHOJIOr11i1, KOTOpbie 1103BOJIHT ell: rrp0113BO,ll;l1Tb Cl1CTeMy caMOCTOHTeJibH06.

CT011T OTMeTl1Tb, qTo peaKu;11H CIIIA 6b1Jia TOH :>Ke, qTo 11 B 2007 r., o,n;HaKo Terrepb Typu;11H, Bl1,ll;l1MO, pernHJia He rrpH,ZJ;aBaTb 6oJibllIOro 3Haqe-

1 i§te Tiirk yap1m1 'Htirku§'un ozellikleri 2 N1san 2009. URL:http://www.hurriyet.eom.tr/ iste-turk-yapimi-hurkusun-ozellikleri-11349023.

2 BoeHHaJI 3Hl\HKJiorre,1111J1. URL: http://www.militaryfactory.com/aircraft/detail. asp?aircraft_id = 1085.

3 BoeHHaJI 3Hl\HKJ10rre,1111J1. URL: http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/europe/ t-loramids.htm.

4 ECJI11 He BH,llHO pa3HH1\hl. URL: https://!enta.ru/articles/2013/06/25/s300vshq9/.

5Htiseyin Bagc1, <;:aglar Kure;. Turkey's strategic choice: buy or make weapons? URL: http://tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14702436.2016.1262742?af=R&journa!Code=f def20.

6Typ1111J1 ,l\oroaop11Jiacb c Pocrne11 o rroeyrrKe C-400. URL: https://rg.ru/2017/07/14/ turciia-dogovorilas-s-rossiej-o-pokupke-s-400.html.

92

HIDI 3aMeqaHIUIM co CTOpOHbl CBoero 3ana,n;Horo napTHepa. B HaCTO.Hrn;ee BpeM.H1neperOBOpbI 0 IlOCTaBKax npo,n;oJDKaIOTC.H H npopa6aTbIBaIOTC.H BIDKHble TeXHuqecKHe ,n;eTaJIH C,ll;eJIKH.

Y'laCTMerype'-'KMXBC BsoeHHblX onepa'-'MHXHATO

B KOHu;e XX - HaqaJie XXI BB. Typu;tt.H 3Haq11TeJ1hHO yKpenHJia csoe coTpy,n;H11qecTBO B paMKax HATO 11 HaqaJia aKTHBHO yqacTBOBaTh B soeHHhIX onepau;mrx, opraHtt3yeMhIX CesepoaTJiaHTHqecKHM aJih.HHCOM, a TaIOKe OOH.

Boop}')KeHHhieCHJihI Typeu;Koif Pecny6J111K11 06ecneq11saJI11 BhIIlOJIHeHHH corJ1arneHHH o npeKparn;eHHH orHH Me)K,ll;y fpy311eH. 11 A6xa3tteH. B oKrn6pe 1994 r.2, a }')KeB 1995 r. np11coe,n;11HHJ1acb K HATO B paMKax soeHHhIX onepau;11:H Ha EaJIKaHax, r,n;e CTaJia rapaHTOM BhIIlOJIHeHIDI ,ll;eHTOHCKHX corJ1arneH11if, npHH.HB yqaCTHe B onepau;uu «COBMeCTHbie ycHJIHH» (Operation Joint Endeavour)3.

KpoMe 3Toro, 1400 COJl,ll;aT Typeu;Koif Pecny6J1HKH sxo,n;HJIH B cesepHJIO ,ll;HBH3HIO BOHCK, KOTOpaH COBMeCTHO c ,ll;BYMH ,n;pyrHMH KOHTpOJIHpOBaJia BhIIlOJ1HeH11e MHpHoro cornarneHHH nocJie 6ocHHHCKOH BOHHhI 19921995 rr. He IlOKHHYJIH BOOp}')KeHHbieCHJlbl Typu;HH EocHHIO H repu;erOBHHY 11 noCJie npeo6pa3oBaHHH MttpornopqecKHX cHJI l1<l>OP B CHJihI no cTa6HJ1113au;1111 (Stabilization Force, SFOR) B paMKax KOTOphIX paHee ,n;eikrnosaJia Typu;ttH4. Ha Tepp11Top1111 rocy,n;apcrna soeHHhie CHJihI Typu;1111 Haxo,n;HJIHCh IlOCJie 3TOro ern;e ,n;Ba c IlOJIOBHHOH ro,n;as.

,JJ;pyroH. MttpornopqecKoif onepau;11eH., B KOTopoH. Typu;ttH TaIOKe np11HHJ1a yqacTtte, CTaJio coxpaHeHtte CTa6HJihHOCTH B KocoBo B 1999 r. Tor,n;a Ha Tepp11Top11u rocy,n;apcTBa, cornacHo oqrnu;11aJ1hHOMY 3aHBJ1eH1110 Ml1,ll; Typu;u11, Haxo,n;HJIOCh 350 TYPeIJ;KHX BOeHHhIX, BXOMIIJ;HX B cocTaB CHJI ,ll;JIH KocoBo (Kosovo Force KFOR)6.

CJ1e,n;y10rn;ttM nyuKTOM B cnttcKe coBpeMeHHhIX BOeHHhIX noxo,n;oB Typ- u;1111 cTaJia MaKe,n;oHIDI. TaM Typu;ttH Haxo,n;HJiacb CHaqaJ1a B paMKax onepa- u;1111 «OCHOBHOH ypO)KaH» (2001) c IJ;eJiblO pa30p}')KeHHHaJI6aHCKHX Boopy- )KeHHbIX <t>opMttpoBaHHH, 3aTeM - B COCTaBe onepau;1111 «5IHTapHbIH JIHC» (2001-2002) c IJ;eJlblO KOHTpOJIH 3a ocyrn;eCTBJleHHeM MHpHoro yperyJ111poBaHHH (coBMeCTHO c EC 11 OECE). 3aTeM noCJie,n;osaJia onepau;IDI «COI03HaH

1 Ha MOMeHT Hami:camrn:, Haqarro ceHT.R6p.R 2017 r.

2 TSK'nm yurt d1§1 ban§ misyonlan 8 Ekim 2003. URL: http://www.hurriyet.eom.tr/ tsknin-yurt-disi-baris-misyonlari-175858.

3 TaM JKe.

4Pe3on1011tt.R CE OOH URL: https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/ N96/362/45/PDF/N9636245. pdf. ?OpenElement.

5TSK'nm yurt dI§I ban§ misyonlan 8 Ekim 2003. URL: http://www.hurriyet.eom.tr/ tsknin-yurt-disi-baris-misyonlari-175858.

6MI1,ll; Typ11utt. URL: http://www.mfa.gov.tr/iv_-european-security-and-defence- identity_policy-_esdi_p_.en.mfa.

93

rapMOHHJI» (2002-2003)' KOTOpaR IIpO,ll;OJDKIDia HaqaryIO pattee onepa- u;mo «.HHTapHbIH JIHC», r,D;e Typu;H:R Ta10Ke np11HRJia yqacT11e1.

Yq11TbIBaJI KoH<i>JIHKTHYIO o6cTaHOBKY 6Jim1rneBOCTOqHoro per110Ha, qacTblO KOTOporo JIBJIJieTCR H Typeu;KM Pecny6JIHKa, rocy,D;apCTBO He MOrJIO He npHBJieKaThCR CeBepoaTJiaHTH:qecKHM aJihRHCOM ,ll;AA yperyJI11poBaHHR BOopy)l{eHHblX KOH<i>JIHKTOB B 3TOM perH:OHe. ,l(JIR IIO,ll;,ll;ep)l{KH BpeMeHHOro opraHa B Ka6yJie 11 o6ecneqeHHR 6eJonacHOCTH B npoBHHQHH Bap- ,Z1;aK2 OKOJIO 2000 TYPeQKHX BOeHHbIX BOIIIJIH B cocTaB Me)K,ll;yHapo,ll;HhIX cHJI co,D;eHCTBHR 6eJonacHOCTH (International Security Assistance Force, ISAF), coJ,D;aHHbIX Ha octtoBaHHH pe30JIIOQHH CoBeTa EeJonacHOCTH OOH NQ 1386 OT 20 ,D;eKa6pR 2001 r.3

IIoCJie BBO,ll;a BOHCK ClllA B HpaK B 2003 r. TYPeu;KHH BOeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT HaqaJI CBOIO ,D;eJITeJibHOCTb Ha TeppHTOpHH coce,D;Hero rocy,D;apCTBa. TaK, B paMKax yqe6Hoi1 MHCCHH HATO (HTM-11) B 2007 r. Typeu;KM Pecny6JIHKa HanpaBHJia B HpaK CBOHX BOeHHbIX 3KCIIepTOB. B 3a,Z1;aq11 MHCCHH H TYPeQKHX BOeHHbIX BXO,ll;HJIO o6yqeHH:e H IIO,ll;rOTOBKa BOeHHbIX Ka,ll;pOB

,ll;JIR l1paKa4.

C anpeAA ,ll;O HIOJIR 2006 r. Typeu;KM Pecny6J111Ka yqacTBOBaJia B «M11cc1111 HATO no naTpyJI11poBaH1110 B03,ll;YlllHOro npoCTpaHCTBa CTpaH EaJITHH» (The Baltic air-policing mission) 5 11 B onepau;1111 «OKeaHCKHH IQHT» (Operation Ocean Shield), HanpaBJieHHOH Ha 6opb6y c COMaJIHHCKHMH n11paTaM116.

Cn11coK onepau;11i1 Typu;1111, npoBe,ll;eHHhIX no;:i; 3rH,ll;OH HATO, B 2011 r. IIOIIOJIHHJICJI eiu;e O,ll;HOH, IIOJl)"IHBllleH Ha3BaHHe «COI03HblH 3aIQHTHHK» (Operation Unified Protector). ll;eJib ;:i;aHHoH: onepau;1111 cocToRJia B o6ecneqeHHH 3M6apro Ha IIOCTaBKH opymHR B J1HBHI07.

B ttacTOHlQHH MOMeHTs BoopymeHHhie CIDibI Typu;1111 npe11Myiu;ecTBeHHO cocpe;:i;oTOqeHhI B C11p111111 HpaKe. B ~eKa6pe 2015 r. Typeu;KM Pecny6JI11Ka BBeJia CBOH BOHcKa B HpaK, B o;:i;tty HJ 11paKcKHX ceBepHbIX npoBHHQHH, r;:i;e pacnoJiaraeTCR HpaKCKHH Kyp;:i;11cTaH. l1HTepectto, qTo Typn;HR, KaK 06b1qHo otta 3TO ;:i;eJiaeT, He yBe,ll;OMHJia o<l>11n;11aJihHOe npaBHTeJibCTBO HpaKa o CBOHX ;:i;ei1cTBHHX. B RHBape npeMbep-MHHHCTp HpaKa XaH,ll;ep aJih-A6a;:i;11 coo6iu;HJI 0 TOM, qTO HpaK H Typn;HR npHIIIJIH K ;:i;oroBopeHHOCTH 0 BbIBe,ll;e- HHH IIOCJie,ll;HeH CBOHX BOHCK, O,ll;HaKO Typn;HR B OTBeT 3aJIBHJia, qTo OCTaBHT

1 3m-111KJiorre,11ID1 HATO. URL: http://www.nato.int/fyrom/home.htm.

2MI1,l\ Typn;1111 URL: http://www.mfa.gov.tr/iv_-european-security-and-defence-identity_ policy-_esdi_p_.en.mfa.

3Pe3omon;m1 Co OOH URL: https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/ NOl/708/57/PDF/NOl 70857.pdf.?OpenElement.

4Pe30Jil01\HH Co OOH URL: https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/ N04/381/18/PDF/N0438118.pdf. ?OpenElement.

5M11,[( Typn;1m. URL: http://www.mfa.gov.tr/iv_-european-security-and-defence- identity_policy-_esdi_p_.en.mfa.

6TaM JKe.

73ttn;11KJiorre,11ID1 HATO. URL: http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/topics_71652.htm.

8Ha MOMeHT Harr11caHID1 MOHorpaqmH, HaqaJIQ MapTa 2017 r.

94

CBOH BOeHHhIH KOHTHHreHT ,ll;O Tex nap, «IlOKa cyrn;ecTByeT yrp03a TeppopH3Ma» 1.

TipHMepHO TaK :lKe Typu;mi: rOBOpHJia H 0 HaqaJie CBOeH onepau;HH B C11p1111 B aBrycTe 2016 r. CornacHo ocl>11u;11aJihHhIM 3aJIBJieHH5IM Ml1,ll; Typeu;Koii Pecny6JIHKH, D;eJih onepau;1111 «~HT EBcl>paTa» (F1rat kalkam) - OTTecHeHHe KYP,ll;OB 3a BOCToqHhIH 6eper EBcl>paTa. B caMoM HaqaJie onepa- u;1111 Typu;1151 3aH5IJia ropo,11; ,ll;:lKapa6Jiyc, HO noo6eiu;aJia, qTo npO,ll;BHHeTCJI ,ll;aJihllie B CJiyqae npo,ll;BH:lKeHHJI KYP,ll;OB K EBcl>pary.

CBOH o6ern;aHH5I Typeu;KaJI Pecny6JIHKa C,ll;ep:lKaJia, H Y:lKe K cl>eBpaJIIO IlO,ll; ee KOHTpoJieM HaXO,ll;HJIC5I 3Jih-Ea6. Typu;H5I TaK:lKe 3axBaTHJia paHOHhl, r,ll;e 6bmH cKoHu;eHTpHpoBaHhI ocHOBHhie KYP,ll;CKHe oTp5I,ll;hI. UeHTpaMH ,11;aHHhIX paiioHoB JIBJIJIIOTCJI Acl>pHH (3ana,11;Hee no,ll;KOHTpoJihHOH TYPKaM Tepp11Top1111) H Ko6aHH (BocrnqHee no,ll;KOHTpOJihHOH Tepp11Top1111) 2.

CJie,ll;yIOiu;eii 3a,11;aqeii CTaJio B35ITHe MaH6H,ll;:lKa - u;eHTpa Kyp,ll;CKHX q,opMHpOBaHHH. 0,11;HaKo, B03MO:lKHO, no,11; ,11;aBJieHHeM ClIIA HJIH ,11;a:lKe PocCHH B KOHu;e MapTa 2017 r. Typu;H5I 3aBepIIIHJia onepau;HIO, TaK H He ycneB BblilOJIHHTb IlOCJie,ll;HIOIO IlOCTaBJieHHYJO D;eJib3.

Ha ,11;eJie 3aBep11IeHHe onepau;1111 oKa3aJIOCh cl>opMaJibHhIM. Typu;HH He roTOBa npoCTO TaK OTCTYfiHTb OT CBOHX u;eJieii, npe,ll;OCTaBHB npHrpaHHqHhie paiioHhI c11p11iicKHM KJ'P,ll;aM.B aBrycTe 2017 r. npe3H,ll;eHT P. T. 3p,11;0- raH 3a5IBHJI, qTQ HaMepeH B0306HOBHTb onepau;HIO H BBeCTH CBOH BOHCKa B ceBepHyIO qacTh l1,ll;Jl116a.

Ha 3TOT pa3 O,ll;HOH H3 rJiaBHbIX u;eJieii CTaHeT BbIBe,ll;eHHe 11,ll;J1116a H3-Il0,ll; KOHTpOJI5I Kyp,ll;OB, a TaK:lKe IlOJiyqeHHe 30Hbl ,ll;e3CKaJiaD;HH B 3TOM pattoHe no,11; cBoii KOHTpOJih4. YqHThIBaJI, qTo B KoHu;e aBrycTa paKeTHOMY o6cTpeJiy TYPeu;Koii apMHH 6bm no,11;BeprHYT ropo,11; Acl>pHH, KOHTpOJIHpyeMhIH Kyp,ll;- CKHM onoJiqeHHeMs, Typu;H5I HacTpOeHa peIIIHTeJibHO, H MHpOBOMY coo6rn;e- CTBY OCTaeTCJI )K,ll;aTh HOBblX BOeHHbIX onepau;Hii c yqacTHeM BOOpY:lKeHHblX CHJI Typeu;Koii Pecny6JIHKH.

,n;o He,ll;aBHero BpeMeHH apMH5I ,ll;eHCTBHTeJibHO HrpaJia 3HaqHMYJO pOJib BO BHeIIIHeii noJIHTHKe Typu;1111. BoeHHhie pe11IaJIH HJIH nhITaJIHCh peIIIaTh HaKOITJieHHbie B o6rn;ecTBe COD;HaJibHO-IlOJIHTHqecKHe, a 3aqacry10 H 3KOHOMHqecKHe BOilpOCbI, O,ll;HaKO B HaCTOJirn;ee BpeMJI IlOJIHTHqecKaJI pOJib apMHH CJia6eeT c Ka)K,ll;hIM ,ll;HeM.

1 B Typn;1u1 pacCKa3aJm o cpoKax BbIBO,lla CBOHX Boi1cK H3 l1paKa. URL: https:// rg.ru/2017/01 /09/v-turcii-rasskazali-o-srokah-vyvoda-svoih-vojsk-iz-iraka.html.

2 «Lijwr EB¢paTa» - nmpMa MH 1)'pn;HH.URL: http://www.kp.ru/daily/26573.4/3588776/. 3 CToqeMy Typn;IDI CJIOJKHJia «mHT EB¢parn». URL: http://www.rbc.ru/politics/30/03/20

17/58dcd0679a79470a56b67b71.

4 CMl1: Typn;mr B03o6ttoBHT B CttpHH orrepan;mo «mHT Ea¢paTa» B ceHTJI6pe. URL: https: / /iz.ru/639065 /2017-08-30I smi-turtciia-vozobnovit-operatciiu-v-sirii-shchit-evfrata-v- sentiabre.

5 Typen;KaJI apnrnJiepHJI o6CTpeJIJIJia cttptti1CKHi1 ropo,11 A¢pttH. URL: https://ria.ru/ syria/20170830/1501354042.html.?inj = 1.

95

fnaBa 6

BOnPOC MCnAMA BnonMTMKE TYPUMM

KaK 11 BO Bcex cTpattax BocToKa, pe1mnrn: 3aH11MaeT 3Haq11Moe MeCTO B )1(113Hl1 Typu;1111. 0,llHaKO B OTJmq11e OT MHor11x 113 Hl1X, pecrry6JI11Ka He HBJIHeTCH TeOKpaT11qeCKl1M rocy,llapCTBOM, me peJI11r11H ycTaHOBJieHa

Ha rocy,llapCTBeHHOM ypOBHe B KaqecTBe o6H3aTeJihHOH.

KaK 113BeCTHO, Typu;HH - CBeTcKoe rocy,llapcTBo, 11 3TOT rrp11ttu;11rr 6bIJI

3aKpeIIJieH eII.J;e M. K. ATanopKoM, a cero,llHH - B rJiaBHOM 3aKotte cTpatthI -

KOHCTl1TYQl111. HecMOTpH Ha 3TO, HaCeJiett11e CTpaHbI 6bIJIO 11 OCTaeTCH peJI11r1103HhIM. IlpeBaJI11pYJOID;aH qacTh TYPeQKOrO 06II.J;eCTBa 11CIIOBe,llyeT 11CJiaM CyttHl1TCKOro TOJIKa

KpoMe 3TOro, HeCMOTpH Ha CBeTCKOCTh 11 Ha TO, qTo IIOJll1Tl1qecK11M rrapTHHM 3arrpeII.J;eHO 11MeTb mo6yJO OTKpbITYJO CBH3h c 11CJiaMOM, OH ttepe,llKO 11CIIOJlh3YeTCH B IIOJil1Tl1qecKl1X u;eJIHX, qTo B 60Jibllil1HCTBe CJiyqaeB He MO)l(eT He OTpa)l(aTbCH Ha IIOJil1Tl1Ke rocy,llapCTBa. B 3TOH CBH311 B03Hl1KaeT Heo6XO,lll1MOCTh IIOHHTh, B KaKl1X cpopMax peJI11r11H rrp11CYTCTByeT B COBpeMeHHOH TYPeQKOH IIOJil1Tl1Ke, KaK 11MeHHO Otta BJll1HeT Ha rrp11HHTl1e rocy,llapcTBeHHhIX peUiett11H: 11 rroqeMy ,l\JIH TYPeo;Koro o6II.J;eCTBa otta 11rpaeT rrp11HQl1IIl1aJibHOe 3fiaqett11e.

KaK J)l(e 6bIJIO OTMeqeHO, B KOHCTl1TYQl1111982 r. yKa3hIBaeTCH, qTo TypQ11H HBJIHeTCH Jia11u;11cTKl1M rocy,llapcTBOM. HapH.l\Y c 3Tl1M B CT. 24, r0Bop11TCH 0 TOM, qTo «H11KOMY He MO)l(eT 6bITh pa3perneHO 3KCIIJiyaT11poBaTh peJI11rl1JO» ,l\JIH ,llOCTl1)1(eHl1H CBOl1X IIOJil1Tl1qecK11x u;eJieH 1. TaKl1M o6pa30M BOeHHbie, COBeplII11BlIIl1e rrepeBOpOT 1980 r. 11 rrp11Hl1MaBUil1e Herrocpe,llCTBeHHOe yqacT11e B pa3pa6oTKe HOBOH KOHCT11ryu;1111, IIhITaJil1Ch MaKCl1MaJihHO OT,llaJil1Th rocy,llapcTBO 11 peJI11rHIO ,llpyr OT ,llpyra.

0,llHaKO rrp11 ,llaHHOM cpopMaJihHOM orpatt11qett1111 peJI11r1151 rrpO,llOJl)l(aJia 11rpaTb Ba)l(HYJO poJib B o6II.J;eCTBeHHOH )1(113Hl1 CTpaHbI, B TOM q11CJie 11 B IIOJil1TttqecKOH ccpepe. Ilpou;ecChI BeCTeptt113ao;1111, HaqaTbie OCHOBaTeJieM Typeu;KoH: Pecrry6JI11K11 MyCTacpoH: KeMaJieM ATaTIOpKoM, rrpe,llIIOJiaraJI11 IIOJIHOe OT,lleJieH11e peJI11r1111 OT IIOJll1Tl1Kl1 11 o6pa30BaHHH, qTo llIJIO Bpa3pe3 c Tpa,L111u;110HHhIM rypeu;K11M YKJia,lloM, B KoTopoM ttCJiaMy Y.lleJIHJIOCh oco6oe MeCTO. 3Tl1M )Ke )l(eJiaH11eM H30JI11pOBaTh 11CJiaM OT o6II.J;eCTBeHHOH )1(113Hl1 o6nHCHHeTCH 11 3arrpeT Tap11KaTOB - peJI11rH03HhIX 06ne,L111Hett11H:,

1 MecTo 11 poJib 11CJiaMa B KoHCTl1T}'lll111 Type~KOH Pecrry6J111KH. URL: http://bibliofond. ru/view.aspx?id = 461036.

97

KOTOpbie BhIH]')K,ZJ;eHhl6bmH yHTH B IlO,ZJ;IIOJibe H BeCTH CBOIO ,z:i;eHTeJihHOCTh

TaHHO.

A,n;anTaQHH 3anap;HblX npHHQHilOB K TypeQKHM peaJIHHM npOXO,ll;HJia TJI)l(eJIO H npaKTHqecKH HHKOrp;a He npHBeTCTBOBaJiaCb HaCeJieHHeM. Ilo BceH: CTpaHe TO H p;eJIO IlOHBJIHJIHCb HOBble HCJiaMHCTCKHe napTHH, a peJIHrHH BhIXO,ll;HJia Ha nepBblH IlJlaH IlOJIHTHqecKOH )l(H3HH, qTO He COOTBeTCTBOBaJIO ycTaHOBJieHHhIM paHee rocy,z:i;apCTBeHHhIM npHHQHilaM H npoBOQHpOBaJIO BMeIIIaTeJibCTBO BOeHHhIX, KOTOphie c rrepBbIX ,ll;HeH: cyIQeCTBOBaHHH pecny6mrnaHCKOH TypQHH HBJIAAHCh rapaHTOM HepyrnHMOCTH KeMaJIHCTCKHX nopH,ll;KOB.

Tpap;HQHOHHO CHJlbHOe BJIHHHHe TaKpHKaTOB TaK)l(e HHey,z:i;a He YIIIJIO. Hx ,z:i;eHTeJihHOCTh 6hma peopraHH30BaHa H He B JiyqlllYJO ,ll;JIH npaBHTeJihCTBa CTOpoHy: IlOHHB, qTo HX npaBa YIQeMJIHIOTCH, a p;eHTeJihHOCTb H BOBCe np11paBHHBaeTCH K 3anpeIQeHHOH, npe,z:i;cTaBHTeJIH TapHKaTOB He npeKpaTHJIH HX CY!QeCTBOBaHHH, a npOCTO HaqaJIH HeJieraJibHYJO p;eHTeJihHOCTh.

HapH,ll;y c 3THM noJIHT11qecK11e napTHH TaK)l(e nepecTaJIH OTKphITO ,z:i;eKJiap11poBaTh HCJiaM H BeCTH nponaraH,z:i;y HCJiaMCKHX QeHHOCTeH B CBOHX nporpaMMax. 0THhIHe TaKHe napTHH Ha3hIBaJIHCb Tpap;HQHOHaJIHCTCKHMH, a HX ,z:i;eHTeJihHOCTh, KaK npamvrn, CBO,ll;HJiaCb K o6pa30BaHHIO opraHH3aQHH, ,ll;BH)l(eHHH H coo6IQeCTB, KOTOpbie Il03BOJIHJIH rro-npe)l(HeMy IlO,ll;,ll;ep)l(HBaTb BJil1HHl1e lfCJiaMa Ha Il0Jll1Tl1KY.

c Il0311Ql111 rocy,z:i;apCTBa KOHTpOJIHpOBaTh TaeyJO ,z:i;eHTeJihHOCTh CTaJIO ropa3,ll;O CJIO)l(Hee, IlOCKOJlhKY eCJilf paHhllle Jllf,ll;epbl no,z:i;o6HhIX opraHH3aQl1H OTKpbITO 3aHBJIHJll1 0 CBOlfX l1CJiaMCKl1X HaCTpoeHlfHX, TO Tenepb TaKoro po,z:i;a H,ll;eH 6hmH YMeJIO 3aByaJ111poBaHhI, 11 ,z:i;oKa3aTh He3aKOHHOCTh cpyttKQl10H11pOBaHl1H opraHl13aQl1H 11 l1X np11qacTHOCTh K IlOJil1TlfqecKOMY lfCJiaMy CTaJIO CJIO)l(Hee.

TeM He Mettee B COOTBeTCTBl111 c ynOMHHYTOH CTaTbeH: KOHCTl1TYQl1H 6bmo 3aKpbITO MHO)l(eCTBO napT11H, qhJI CBH3b c lfCJiaMOM 6bma ,ll;OKa3aHa B cy,z:i;e. KpynHettllleH 113 Hl1X CTaJia IlapT11H 6Jiaro,z:i;eHCTBl1H, OCHOBaHHaH 11,z:i;eoJioroM noJI11T11qecKoro lfCJiaMa B TypQ1111 11 JI11,z:i;epoM ,ll;Bl1)1(eH11H «MHJIJIH replOIIl» He,ll;)l(MeTTlfHOM 3p6aKaHOM.

B 1998 r. KoHCTl1TYQl10HHhIH cy,z:i; TypQHH nocTaHOBHJI, qTo p;eHTeJihHOCTh napT1111 He3aKOHHa BBH,ll;Y HapyrneH11H ,z:i;eH:cTBYJOIQeH: KoHCTl1TYQl111, B qacTHOCTlf np11HQ11Ila ceeyMp113Ma1. Ilp11MeqaTeJihHO, qTO He3ap;OJiro ,ll;O 3aKpbITl1H napT11H B 1997 r. 6bIJia OCHOBaHa IlapTl1H ,z:i;o6po,z:i;eTeJIH, KOTOpaH npo- ,ll;OJI)l(aJia CJie,z:i;oBaTh H,ll;eHM 3p6aKaHa. Ee ocHoBaTeJih HcMaHJI AnhnTeK11H 3MBJIHJI, qTO QeJIHMlf napT1111 HBJIHIOTCH IlOCTpoeH11e ,z:i;eMOKpaTHlf 11 3aIQl1Ta npaB rpa)l(p;aH no np11Mepy 3anap;HhIX cTpaH, o,z:i;HaKo ee Bee paBHO np11n11cb1BaJI11 K l1CJiaMl1CTCKl1M 11 Tpa,ll;l1Ql10HaJIHCTCKl1M, qTo BilOCJie,ll;CTBl111 11 cTaJio np11q11HoH: ee 3anpeTa B 2001 r.

BhIXO,ll;QhI 113 IlapT1111 ,z:i;o6po,z:i;eTeJil1, B TOM q11CJie 11 Pep;)l(en TaH:11n 3p,z:i;o- raH, OCHOBaJilf HOBYIO IlOJll1TlfqecKylO CHJIY - IlapT11IO cnpaBe,ll;Jil1BOCTl1

1 Turkey's Welfare Party is banned. URL: http://news.bbc.eo.uk/2/hi/middle_east/48001. stm.

98

H pa3BHTHH, c rrpHXO,ll;OM K BJiaCTH KOTOpoH: Haqanacb HOBaH 3110Xa Typeu;- Koro rocy.zi;apcTBa.

HecMOTpH Ha rrpoqH)'IOCBH3h c rrpOIIIJihIMH rrapTHHMH 11 HCJiaMHCTCKHMH H,zi;eHMH B u;e.noM, JIH,zi;ep c03,zi;aHHOH TICP OTOIIIeJI OT pa.zi;ttKanhHOro KYPCa, 06'hHBHBrrapTHID «KOHCepBaTHBHO .zi;eMOKpaTHqecKOH» 1. fJiaBHhIMH D;eJIHMH rrapTHH 6hmtt rrpoBo3rJiaIIIeHhI BCTYITJieHtte Typu;tttt B EBpocoro3 H pacurnpeHHe KOHTaKTOB c 3arra.zi;oM, qTo IIIJIO Bpa3pe3 c H,zi;eHMH 3p6aKaHa 0 ry6ttTeJihHOCTH 3arra,zi;HhIX u;eHHOCTeH: MH Typeu;Koro o6rn;ecTBa.

Tipttq11H ,zi;JIH H3MeHeHHH KYPCa 6hmo HeCKOJihKO, H rJiaBHaH 113 HHX - OC03HaHHe, qTo rrapTHH, .zi;a)Ke KOCBeHHO 060.IIBJIHIDID;a.II 0 JIID6hIX CBH3.IIX c peJIHrtteH:, He crroco6Ha ,ll;OJiroe BpeMH rrpo.zi;yKTHBHO yrrpaBJIHTh CTpaHOH. KpoMe 3Toro, 3p.zi;oraH rrpe.zi;rroJiaran, qTo ycHJieHtte CBH3eH: c 3arra.zi;oM H IlOCJie,zi;yrorn;aH 3a 3THM ,zi;eMOKpaTH3au;HH o6rn;eCTBa 1103BOJIHT CHH3HTh ypoBeHh BJIHHHHH BOeHHhIX B CTPaHe, KOTOphie 6hmH rJiaBHhIMH 3arn;ttTHHKaMH CBeTCKHX rrpHHD;HilOB.

TIOJIHTHKa, KOTopyro Haqana rrpOBO,ll;HTh rrapTHH, H3HaqaJihHO, .zi;eH:CTBHTeJihHO, OTBeqaJia o6'hHBJieHHhIM.zi;eMOKpaTHqecKHM u;eJIHM. TiocJie 3KOHOMHqecKoro Kp11311ca 2001 r. TICP TecHo pa6oTana c Me)K,zi;yHapo,zi;HhIM BaJIIDTHhIM cpott.zi;oM ,zi;AA rrpeo,zi;oJieHHH 3KOHOM11qecKoro crra.zi;a. B paMKax rrporpaMMhI, rrpe.zi;no)KeHHOH MB<I>, Typu;HH pacIIIttpHJia CBH3H c 3arra,zi;HhIMH HHBeCTopaMH, rrpHBJieKaH HHOCTPaHHhie KaITHTa.lihl B CBOID 3KOHOMHKY, qTo 1103BOJIHJIO eH: BhIHTH Ha KaqecTBeHHO HOBhIH ypoBeHh pa3BHTH.II.

MeTO,lJ;hI rrpttMeHeHHH ,zi;eMoKpaTH3au;tttt rrpoCJie)KttBaJIHCh H B .zi;pyrttx

.zi;eH:crnttHx Typeu;Koro PYKOBo,zi;crna. HarrpttMep, 6hm BBe,zi;eH ocpttu;ttanhHhIH 3arrpeT Ha CMepTHYID Ka3Hh, rrpOBO,lJ;HJiaCh IlOJIHTHKa CMJirqeHHH B OTHOIIIeHHH Hau;ttoHaJihHhIX MeHhIIIHHCTB, XOTH B HTOre Hau;ttoHaJihHhIH BOrrpoc TaK

H OCTaJICH HepeIIIeHHhIM.

~eMoKpaTttqecKHH KYPC BO BHeIIIHeH: rroJIHTHKe rrpoHBHJICH B rrepByID oqepe.zi;h 3a cqeT pacIIIttpeHHH CBH3eH: c EC H CIIIA, KOTOphie cTaJIH aKTHBHO yKperrJIHThCH, B TOM qlfCJie 110 3KOHOMHqecKHM rrpHqHHaM. TipH 3TOM CJie-

.zi;yeT 3aMeTHTh, qTo Typu;HH BOCilpHHHMaJia COTpy.zi;HttqecTBO c 3arra,zi;oM He KaK 3aMetty KOHTaKTaM c perHOHa.lihHhIMH coce,ll;HMH, a KaK ,ll;OilOJIHeHHe K HHM, TeM caMhIM CTPeMHCh rronyqttTh B03MO)KHOCTh rrpo.zi;JKTHBHO coTpy.zi;- HttqaTh co BCeMH.

MHoroBeKTOpHhIH xapaKTep BHeIIIHeH: H BHYTpeHHeH: rrOJIHTHKH IT03BOJIHJI TICP 3HaqttTeJihHO YKPeITHTh CBOH rro3HD;HH Ha BHYTPHITOJIHTttqecKoH: apeHe, qTo CTaJio oco6eHHO 3aMeTHO B pe3yJihTaTe BhI6opoB B 2007 r., Kor.zi;a rrapTHH rroJiyqHJia 46,6 % roJiocoB rrptt 34 % Ha Bh16opax 2002 r. TaKHM o6pa30M, IICP y,zi;aJIOCh rroBhICHTh JIOHJihHOCTh K ce6e BO Bcex perttoHax CTpaHhI, B TOM qlfCJie H caMOM rrpo6JieMHOM - IDrO-BOCTOqHOM c rrpeo6Jia,ll;aIDrn;HM KYP,ll;CKHM HaceneHtteM.

0,zi;HaKO rrpH Bcex ,zi;eMOKpaTHqecKHX Mepax Typeu;Koe pyKOBO,ll;CTBO OCTaBaJIOCh rJiy6oKO BepHbIM CBOHM rrepBOHaqaJihHhIM H,ll;e.IIM. 3p.zi;oraH

1 Senem Aydin and Ru§en <;:ak1r. Political Islam in Turkey 2007. URL: http://aei.pitt. edu/11663/1/1490.pdf.

99

Bcer,a;a C'IHTaJI,'ITOHCJiaM ,ll;OJI)l(eH CTaTb HeOT'beMJieMOHqacTblO )l(H3HH C1'paHbI,O,D;HaKO Ha Ha'IaJibHOM3Tane CBoe:H p;e.flTeJibHOCTH B paMKax f1CP He Mor HX oc~eCTBHTb, IIOCKOJlbKj'BCe-TaKH CJie,D;OBaJI npo3aIIa,D;HbIM u;eHHOCT.flM.

Ba)l(HO, 'ITOnpoHCJiaMCKHe H,D;eH 3p,a;oraHa oT'IaCTHpa3,a;eJI.flJio HaceJieHHe, KOTOpoe 6bIJIO MOpaJibHO rOTOBO K no,a;o6HbIM nepeMeHaM IIO HeCKOJib-

KHM IIpH'IHHaM.fJiaBHa.fl H3 HHX - TOT cpaKT, 'ITOIIpH Bcex CTapaHH.flX

ATaTIDpKa H ,a;pyrHx JIH,D;epoB Hapo,a;Ho-pecny6JIHKaHcKo:H napTHH, npH aKTHBHOM BOeHHOM BMeIIIaTeJibCTBe HCJiaMCKOe BJIH.flHHe He y,a;aJIOCb JIHKBH,ll;HpOBaTb IIOJIHOCTbl01, a Ha cpoHe Hey,a;a'IHbIXneperoBopoB 0 BCTYIIJieHHH B EC B 1990-x rr. TYPeu;Koe o6m;ecTBO CTaJIO cKeIITH'IeCKHOTHOCHTbC.fl K H,D;ee IIOJIHOro OTKa3a OT peJIHrHH. floMHMO 3Toro, B Te rO,D;bI MO)l(HO 6bIJIO Ha6JIIO,D;aTb aKTHBH3aI.J;HIO MHO)l(eCTBa peJIHrH03HbIX ,ll;BH)l(eHHH B Typu;HH " 3a ee npe,a;eJiaMH, 'ITOHaIIpRMYID cnoco6cTBOBaJIO B03HHKHOBeHHIO npoHCJiaMCKHX HaCTpoeHHH B IIOJIHTH'IeCKOH)l(H3HH CTpaHbl.

0,a;HHM H3 no,a;o6HbIX o6'be,D;HHeHHH.flBJl.fIIOTC.fl TapHKaTbI, KOTOpbie npe,a;- CTaBJl.fllOT co6o:H HeopTo,a;oKCaJibHbie o6'he,a;uHeHH.flMYCYJibMaH, MR KOTopbIX xapaKTepeH MHCTHI.J;H3M, a TaK)l(e II03HaHHe 6ora HeCTaH,a;apTHbIMH

,ll;Jl.fl HCJiaMa cnoco6aMH, HanpHMep qepe3 OTIIIeJibHH'IeCTBOHJIH acKeTH3M. IlpHBep)l(eHu;bI TapHKaTOB O'IeHbpeJIHrH03HbI " IIpH 3TOM BepHbI CBOHM HaCTaBHHKaM, B no,a;o6HbIX opraHH3aI.J;H.flX CHJibHO pa3BHTbI KOJIJieKTHBH3M

H o6m;HOCTb.

HaH6oJiee aKTHBHbIMH TapHKaTaMH B Typu;uu .flBJI.fllOTC.fl HaKrn6eH,a;H, Hyp,a;)l(y H CyJie:HMaH,ll;)l(H. flepBbIH npHrneJI B Typu;uID H3BHe, ,a;pyrue )Ke B03HHKJIH BH)'TpHKaK OTBeTHbie ,n;eikTBH.fl Ha paCIIIHpRIOm;eeC.fl pacrrpoCTpaHeHHe IIpHHI.J;HIIa ceKyJIRpH3Ma. 11MeHHO OTpuu;aHHe IIpHHI.J;HIIa CBeTCKOCTH H .flBJl.fleTC.fl o6'he,D;HH.fllOIIl;HMIIyttKTOM Bcex no,n;o6HbIX peJIHrH03HbIX

o6m;ecTB. ·

MHorHe Be,D;~He IIOJIHTHKH pecny6JIHKaHCKOH Typu;uu He CKpbIBaJIH CBoe:H npuBep)l(eHHOCTH K TOMY HJIH HHOMY TapHKary. TaK, no BepcHH p.fl,ll;a

TYPeI.J;KHX HCCJie,a;oBaTeJie:H, npeMbep-MHHHCTpbI A,ll;HaH MeH,D;epec H Typr)'T 03aJI HMeJIH TeCHbie CB.fl3H c op,a;eHoM HaKrn6eH,a;H. CBR3b Be,n;~ux IIOJIHTH-

KOB H 6H3HeCMeHOB CTpaHbI c peJIHrH03HbIMH o6m;uHaMH npocJie)l(HBaeTC.fl H B COBpeMeHHOH Typu;HH, KOTOpaR 3a nepBoe ,n;eC.flTHJieTHe xx B. 3Ha'IHTeJibHO H3MeHHJia IIOJIHTHKY B OTHOIIIeHHH no,a;o6HbIX o6'be,D;HHeHHH.

He OCTaJIHCb B CTOpOHe H 60JibIIIHHCTBO JIH,ZJ;epOB HOBOH napTHH, KOTOpbie TaK)l(e 6bIJIH 'IJieHaMHpa3JIH'IHbIXpeJIHrH03HbIX TapHKaTOB (K IIpHMepy, no HeKOTOpbIM cBe,a;eHHRM, 3p,a;oraH " HbIJI,ll;bipbIM HMeJIH CB.fl3H c TapHKaTOM HaKIII6eH,D;H)'MHOrHe H3 napJiaMeHTapHeB H 'IJleHOBKa6uHeTa MHHHCTpOB 6bIJIH 'IJleHaMHflapTHH ,a;o6po,n;eTeJIH (B qacTHOCTH, MHHHCTp o6opoHbI Typu;uH <f>HKpH blIIIbIK), a MHHHCTP IDCTHI.J;HH EeKHp 503,a;ar 6hm 'IJleHOMflapTHH 6Jiaro,a;eHCTBH.fl 3p6aKaHa.

1 ABamKOB B. A. Type11KaJ1 ,11eMOKpanf3aI1IDI B 90-e - KJllO'I K cero,11HJIIIIHei1 HCJiaMJ.13allHH Typ11ww I I nJIH)KHHi1 BocToK H coBpeMeHHOCTh. 2012. NQ 45. URL: https://mgimo.ru/ upload/iblock/73e/73eaf8946d20e682e2a5507a7c61569d.pdf.

100