!Экзамен зачет учебный год 2023-2024 / Cennaya_bumaga_protiv_sekyuritis-unprotected

:

versus

" #$ , !$ ( % ) # *. + * * " # " #$

$%, # * " , # # , ( * . "$ - $ # " #$

$%, * * # "*$

- . /$ # , ,

) # * * " 0 # , "

# # ! *0 , ,

-# $ 1 $%,

0 , 0 # %(

! *0 . 90-0 $

" #$ * ! *0 ; " ,$ ,

( $ # * *$ !$ - 4 , % ($ ! *0 $% (§ 1, 2);

# " ! $% #

" #$ * ! *0 , * %# *

! * $% ! * (§ 3).

§ 1. "

8.

«! » % * ". *-

«! » $ ,$ $ " #,

) # 0, *

1

. .

" , %, $ "- . ,, - (

> ;.;. 8 , , , " #$

«! » -

- : $" «# " , # , #1

*0 0 # # ( *-*0 0 »2. @"- ;.;. 8 * - (

1 * , ,$ ( # $ "

! *0 0 (. ! *

$ #, # Thol , "# 1875 ., " ! # (- #- 3. G (, " 7 ) * Brunner’ 4, - *

#- # ! : –

,

5. O # 0 !

# %( " #$ , %, $ (.

P " # ! % # *

$%, &6 '.

( # *, * "* % ! * , $ , 0 * % # : valeurs

1!.!. / * . <, ! *0 0, ;., 1994 ., T. 180 ( 4

*, # , *, . 23 PU VTWTV 1922 . "1 " *0

! *0 ; - * «! » . 30 - *0

) # *0 -0 ) # *0 # 0 *0 -0).

28 ;.;. < ". ,., T. 180.

3Thol, Handelsrecht, 1875, B. I § 201.

4Brunner, Die Wertpapiere, Endermann’l Handbuch des deutschen Handels, - See – und Wechselrechts, B. II, 1882.

5«Wertpapier ist eine Urkunde ueber ein Privatrecht, dessen Verwertung durch die Innehabung der Urkunde privatrechtlich bedingt ist».

6 /$ $ #0 # $ , , $ #, " " #$ * " " !, , , * *-% ! ,

# % " . "$ , Rektapapiere, " *

! * , $ * " % (8 ;.;.,

< ". ,., T. 183).

2

. .

) % " ! , # ( # *0 ! *0 -

m , , * # – 4 # #-

- , * , , * #$ # * ) $*

; # *, * " " %, % # * %# 0 #

# # 0 #, " % - , * % #, ,

* * $ " , , "-*0

$ *10. securities, , $

$" , 4 ! , ;.;. 8

. O (security) # #

) ( $ .

o. ,- - -

@ " ! *0 "*, , -# ( #- # "

* 0 " ( "#- , " %( 0 !

( *0 . # , # 4 ! " #$

7 O ) ! " * % ! ,

88 ;.;. < ". ,., T. 183.

9) m $ U $" * negotiable instrument effet de commerce " " * (See: Leclair J. L'interaction entre le droit privé fédéral et le droit civil québécois en matière d'effets de commerce: perspective constitutionnelle, 40 McGill L.J. 691, 1995).

104 5. P-# Tx8 ( )., ;., 1961, T. 621. - P. m

# 0 # 0, * * * " # * , *

*0 # , * , # 0. O # * " , *

# * # * # , * #$ ( * # , , #-*

-), - #$ ! 0, * ! !.

3

. .

$" , * # * . O , * ! *0 " %, , ,, #

*, # #- , ! " ,

#- " #$ . T # *, # #

) ! # "* % , #- 12.

, * " ) ! % ( !$% #, %( 0

" !$ - $ , 4

"# ) !. + 0 - " ,

, #, 4 , " $ # * –

, # " #$ $" #

! 13, , 0 # - !

$" # 14.

o " ,$* " , * #- $% #

118 ;.;. < ". T ,., T. 225.

12+ , ! , # ! *0 " #$ "- ,

13+ , P , x !, @, V.

14+ , negotiable instruments/securities, effets de commerce/valeurs mobilieres.

15/ 0-# " , . : Glaeser E.L., Shliefer A. Legal Origins, Quarterly Journal of Economics, pp. 1193-1229 (, * %, , # " * # #

" ( -# * , % # , "$ :

, $ # , $ #- *$ $ " *

#. /# " # " # *

> *0 # – %, " ! # .

4

. .

" ($ ! * , - $, , -

! *0 # % $ # # #-

" #.

#- " . " #$ , ,

§ 2. " 17

8.

1929 . 8 * , ) * ", ,

- # # " 1933 . 1934 .18, 0

" $ * - #$ ", , # ! ( -#

) $ 12-13 0, # 8 %#$ $ , 4

>$ - - 0 " -", , *" -" * #* ! *0

) # * Tx8. - T., 2003 . !-> . . | * ( $*

" *0 0 V Tx8) // P # , 1997, • 1, T. 83-91.

5

. .

# " * . O " * % * *

, * * ( * ) # * 19,

( # 4 " * 0 #- -

* ) !, #-

20.

+ " *0 " « $%» (“security”)21 $"$, -# , # " , ! *0

! *0 (!, !), # *0 # 4 " !, , $ , # 0 #,

*0 " * *0 #, # * « $%» " "#

*0 .

( %, !$ *0 " # %( :

B B C -

>, B-

18 W. Werner’ , «) #$ " #$ $% * U !$% ). U - * ,- #$ # 4» (See: Werner W. The SEC as a Market Regulator, 70 Virginia Law Review, 1984, p. 755).

" * $*, 8# ! U, "$ " !

!, # # , " ( $%.

0 * . T ) 0

#- * : , " # , $ #

4 *. , ##- " ,$* # *

, U - G $% 1933 . - # , *

# $ $ " ( (See: Christian J. Meier-Schatz, Disclosure Rules In The U.S., Germany And Switzerland, The American Journal of Comparative Law, 1986, vol. 34, p. 273274).

20 P x ! # * $ " * , , *

* 1 . * ) !

* 1870 ., # P - * *

%( " . /#, , , 4 " $

) !$ # " ! # «!»

* "# % # , 0 !. C.J. Meier-Schatz’ , * #- $

( « $ » # ! # $0 , -

* , *0 0 " (See: Christian J. Meier-Schatz, ibid., p. 276-277, 282).

21 / " « $%» >.8. ! , , « ,$

“security” 0 * %,$ # * # * * "

" %,$ " $% «,$» #, # % # ) 0-# # , 4 $"$ # " ,

6

. .

- ( # # ! " , *,

, " $0 ! (SEC v. W.J. Howey), " 24, " (

* ) ! ( $ ) ! 25).

" , $%, " ,$ $"$

# " , ! *0 C ,

,$ " , * , 4 ! * #

# «! * »26.

Tx8 ($% " $% * %(

* . T 4 " * "# 0

% # , 27 , % $ ,

# 0 , ) # # "#

!$ . "$ , " #$ $%

$* 0.

o. ,- - -

8 ! " #$ $% !$ #

* " * , " 28. O, ,,

22 T) "#$ !$ " - ( * #0 # %

#$ * ) ! , " « #$ * , ! !» (“accuracy enhancement” model). ;-# * " $ , ",

#$ * 0 # # . . *

(, # ), * ) ! % *, *0,

% *0 # 0 0, ,, - "$ # % ! , – « #$ ( 0 0 #» (“agency cost model”). # . Mahoney P.G. Mandatory Disclosure as a Solution to Agency Problems, 62 U. Chi. Rev. 1047-1112.

23@# * ) ! * *, *- # %( 0

" *0 *-0: « K >; B

K B - ».

24"$ $ " ! " # , $%

) !, ,, " « #» #-, " #

T !. <, * 2001 . , + % % «" 0 " *

) !».

26Marc I. Steinberg, Understanding Securities Law, New York, 1996, p. 17-20.

27N. Moloney , , %( * * «

# $%, " 1933 . 1934 ., "# $ * " % % ,

$ 0 % # % » (See: Moloney N. EC Securities Regulation. Oxford,

2002, p. 4). + #, , #- " * " * "# «* " %

% », " ,$ , $% , ,, " %, #- ($ %( .

28 + , † " # , M. Yazawa, ,

$% " * T # *0 x, %( # $% (See:

7

. .

1 # - $%. ;- #

, *0 " # "- " #$ : ( ) , " !$ , # " #$

% $%. + , * # # ) , " #$ -# )

) ! " # ( " *0 ! *0 , $

. T) 4 0 !, # , (

# " !$ , , *

%( $ # 4 ) * 0 # *

# * . @" 4 #, , " %( 0

Japan securities regulation, editor, with Loss L. and Yazawa M., 1983, p. 24). /# # M. Yazawa

", , - * " * - % ,

% T # *0 x 0, $" % .

: 1. ) * !, # * ) *, ) * , *

) * , #, ! * ) *, * 0- # *, # %(

!$%; 2. ( , ! *, )$%, *, # ! 0 * #, 0- , * " *; 3. ) *, # %( " * * ! *

; 4. ", # %( " * * ! * (art. 1 sec. a).

31 @ < " • 58 24 ) 1998 . . 1 (2) ) *0 0,

*0, ,, " * ! # ( * ! * , *

# % ; ! # ( * # * ! * ;

! ) #; ! * , * *, ( % #- *; # ! * , # %( * " *0 ! *0 ; )$%, *;

*; ) # * * # ) * *.

8

. .

-" *0 $ # «! » %

4 0 0 - $ .

-*0, 32 0 - *

! *0 # # 0

* . V - " #$

4 , " # * #* ! *0 33. / , 4,,, " $" # 0 ! *0 , *0

(# , )34. G #$ 4 0 0 ,

) !, # ,, # ( ) 0

! * ( ) - # * ) ) !. , # , (

% " % $, , 4 , *

" #$ # , *

# 4 # " #$ .

# * *0 $" % *

# * ", # 0 -#

$" : Howey, , ! *0 # 0

32 T . ) " § 1o ( $ .

33 -# , 4 !, !, ! 0 , ! *0

! ! *0 , , " ( *0 " ( #

) #$* " * * * VW, - # ,

(-# % ) # % "* " *: # – « ! *0 0», # – « * ( ) ! *0 » ( , P , x !, V).

9

. .

, " *, , - # # . < " *

", % , # % "# $

$% !. + , x ! # " % , , %( * #-* *$

* - 36.

" #$ , 0, #

#$, (# , )

$%, # " ,$ % . -

, - " #$ , (

- , $ , , #

$ , * #, $ %

" * % ) ! $ # 0 !, #

* #$ -# % 4 . +, " #$

-# , 0 # $*

( , "$* * ,

* # % ,, -# %( - " (

( , ) «, * " $0 !» "* ! *

0 $%), * " * "# % #

# . $, #- $*, 0 # - 0

#, "#$ *, , % ($% " 1 4 0 -

, # *0 %( #* %.

10

. .